{"year": 2026, "matched_reviews": 74380, "by_rating": {"0": {"n_reviews": 1279, "units_per_review": 5.4, "valence": {"positive": 0.0362, "negative": 0.911, "conditional": 0.0352, "uncertain": 0.0135, "mixed": 0.0041}, "standards": {"merit_recognition": 0.0509, "presentation_trust": 0.1669, "novelty_standard": 0.2318, "claim_evidence_match": 0.0471, "fair_comparison": 0.0745, "design_justification": 0.1802, "robustness_norm": 0.0469, "statistical_identifiability": 0.0642, "cost_benefit": 0.023, "construct_validity": 0.0358, "confound_hypothesis": 0.0326, "reproducibility_norm": 0.0461}, "improve_rate": 0.6747, "mean_confidence": 4.23}, "2": {"n_reviews": 19430, "units_per_review": 5.63, "valence": {"negative": 0.8534, "uncertain": 0.0269, "positive": 0.0567, "conditional": 0.0584, "mixed": 0.0046}, "standards": {"reproducibility_norm": 0.0331, "robustness_norm": 0.0721, "novelty_standard": 0.1844, "fair_comparison": 0.1023, "presentation_trust": 0.092, "claim_evidence_match": 0.0602, "design_justification": 0.2035, "construct_validity": 0.036, "cost_benefit": 0.0423, "confound_hypothesis": 0.0448, "merit_recognition": 0.0722, "statistical_identifiability": 0.057}, "improve_rate": 0.7781, "mean_confidence": 3.87}, "4": {"n_reviews": 29204, "units_per_review": 5.43, "valence": {"negative": 0.747, "positive": 0.1112, "conditional": 0.0931, "uncertain": 0.0416, "mixed": 0.0071}, "standards": {"novelty_standard": 0.1512, "claim_evidence_match": 0.0696, "statistical_identifiability": 0.0471, "merit_recognition": 0.1168, "fair_comparison": 0.0931, "design_justification": 0.1963, "cost_benefit": 0.0589, "confound_hypothesis": 0.0452, "robustness_norm": 0.0953, "presentation_trust": 0.0654, "construct_validity": 0.0334, "reproducibility_norm": 0.0278}, "improve_rate": 0.7802, "mean_confidence": 3.59}, "6": {"n_reviews": 19372, "units_per_review": 5.51, "valence": {"positive": 0.2133, "negative": 0.5978, "conditional": 0.1227, "uncertain": 0.0569, "mixed": 0.0093}, "standards": {"merit_recognition": 0.196, "novelty_standard": 0.1232, "robustness_norm": 0.1066, "claim_evidence_match": 0.072, "fair_comparison": 0.0744, "design_justification": 0.1688, "cost_benefit": 0.0662, "presentation_trust": 0.0583, "confound_hypothesis": 0.0424, "construct_validity": 0.0318, "statistical_identifiability": 0.0356, "reproducibility_norm": 0.0246}, "improve_rate": 0.7144, "mean_confidence": 3.41}, "8": {"n_reviews": 4910, "units_per_review": 5.68, "valence": {"positive": 0.3237, "negative": 0.4548, "conditional": 0.1472, "uncertain": 0.0649, "mixed": 0.0094}, "standards": {"novelty_standard": 0.116, "merit_recognition": 0.289, "cost_benefit": 0.0604, "design_justification": 0.1437, "claim_evidence_match": 0.0662, "robustness_norm": 0.0904, "construct_validity": 0.0256, "reproducibility_norm": 0.023, "statistical_identifiability": 0.0232, "presentation_trust": 0.0676, "fair_comparison": 0.0575, "confound_hypothesis": 0.0374}, "improve_rate": 0.6286, "mean_confidence": 3.55}, "10": {"n_reviews": 185, "units_per_review": 6.01, "valence": {"negative": 0.348, "positive": 0.4011, "conditional": 0.1655, "uncertain": 0.0818, "mixed": 0.0036}, "standards": {"design_justification": 0.1412, "merit_recognition": 0.3345, "presentation_trust": 0.0836, "claim_evidence_match": 0.0486, "reproducibility_norm": 0.0207, "novelty_standard": 0.1358, "construct_validity": 0.0207, "fair_comparison": 0.0504, "robustness_norm": 0.0809, "cost_benefit": 0.045, "statistical_identifiability": 0.0144, "confound_hypothesis": 0.0243}, "improve_rate": 0.5647, "mean_confidence": 3.88}}}