{"baseline": {"n": 19474, "n_decided": 13704, "accept": 0.3904, "objects": {"empirical_scope": 0.9119, "baselines_ablations": 0.7067, "theory": 0.7098, "method_design": 0.7867, "compute_cost": 0.6385, "clarity": 0.6887, "novelty": 0.3794, "related_work": 0.3581, "stats_metrics": 0.7447, "robustness_sensitivity": 0.5012, "reproducibility": 0.2633, "problem_framing": 0.2935}}, "areas": {"CV / audio / language applications": {"n": 2687, "n_decided": 1684, "accept": 0.4359, "objects": {"empirical_scope": 0.9617, "baselines_ablations": 0.7737, "theory": 0.6103, "method_design": 0.8039, "compute_cost": 0.6818, "clarity": 0.6855, "novelty": 0.399, "related_work": 0.329, "stats_metrics": 0.7261, "robustness_sensitivity": 0.4734, "reproducibility": 0.2747, "problem_framing": 0.2702}}, "foundation & frontier models (LLMs)": {"n": 2623, "n_decided": 1913, "accept": 0.4412, "objects": {"empirical_scope": 0.8948, "baselines_ablations": 0.7236, "theory": 0.6477, "method_design": 0.8578, "compute_cost": 0.6988, "clarity": 0.6371, "novelty": 0.3538, "related_work": 0.3237, "stats_metrics": 0.7526, "robustness_sensitivity": 0.5227, "reproducibility": 0.2421, "problem_framing": 0.2951}}, "alignment, fairness & safety": {"n": 1667, "n_decided": 1155, "accept": 0.3662, "objects": {"empirical_scope": 0.9382, "baselines_ablations": 0.6389, "theory": 0.6743, "method_design": 0.8074, "compute_cost": 0.5687, "clarity": 0.6563, "novelty": 0.4031, "related_work": 0.3785, "stats_metrics": 0.793, "robustness_sensitivity": 0.5309, "reproducibility": 0.2663, "problem_framing": 0.3227}}, "generative models": {"n": 1646, "n_decided": 1145, "accept": 0.4349, "objects": {"empirical_scope": 0.9168, "baselines_ablations": 0.7357, "theory": 0.7509, "method_design": 0.7515, "compute_cost": 0.6756, "clarity": 0.6823, "novelty": 0.3633, "related_work": 0.3074, "stats_metrics": 0.7211, "robustness_sensitivity": 0.4878, "reproducibility": 0.2388, "problem_framing": 0.2357}}, "datasets & benchmarks": {"n": 1551, "n_decided": 1059, "accept": 0.4136, "objects": {"empirical_scope": 0.9697, "baselines_ablations": 0.528, "theory": 0.3611, "method_design": 0.795, "compute_cost": 0.4952, "clarity": 0.6783, "novelty": 0.4088, "related_work": 0.3888, "stats_metrics": 0.9059, "robustness_sensitivity": 0.4249, "reproducibility": 0.4455, "problem_framing": 0.3056}}, "representation learning": {"n": 1146, "n_decided": 810, "accept": 0.3309, "objects": {"empirical_scope": 0.9468, "baselines_ablations": 0.7321, "theory": 0.7679, "method_design": 0.7304, "compute_cost": 0.651, "clarity": 0.7155, "novelty": 0.3813, "related_work": 0.3805, "stats_metrics": 0.6972, "robustness_sensitivity": 0.5524, "reproducibility": 0.2182, "problem_framing": 0.2897}}, "reinforcement learning": {"n": 1050, "n_decided": 794, "accept": 0.3866, "objects": {"empirical_scope": 0.7829, "baselines_ablations": 0.7695, "theory": 0.8448, "method_design": 0.8933, "compute_cost": 0.6514, "clarity": 0.7095, "novelty": 0.3819, "related_work": 0.3762, "stats_metrics": 0.7124, "robustness_sensitivity": 0.5514, "reproducibility": 0.2076, "problem_framing": 0.3038}}, "physical-science applications": {"n": 846, "n_decided": 591, "accept": 0.3723, "objects": {"empirical_scope": 0.9468, "baselines_ablations": 0.8286, "theory": 0.792, "method_design": 0.7553, "compute_cost": 0.6253, "clarity": 0.7021, "novelty": 0.4078, "related_work": 0.3629, "stats_metrics": 0.7695, "robustness_sensitivity": 0.5024, "reproducibility": 0.3026, "problem_framing": 0.2683}}, "other topics": {"n": 795, "n_decided": 537, "accept": 0.3073, "objects": {"empirical_scope": 0.9057, "baselines_ablations": 0.6981, "theory": 0.7862, "method_design": 0.7358, "compute_cost": 0.7094, "clarity": 0.683, "novelty": 0.3396, "related_work": 0.3635, "stats_metrics": 0.7447, "robustness_sensitivity": 0.5547, "reproducibility": 0.2667, "problem_framing": 0.2855}}, "interpretability & XAI": {"n": 776, "n_decided": 556, "accept": 0.3597, "objects": {"empirical_scope": 0.9433, "baselines_ablations": 0.6108, "theory": 0.7487, "method_design": 0.8389, "compute_cost": 0.4472, "clarity": 0.7616, "novelty": 0.3737, "related_work": 0.3892, "stats_metrics": 0.817, "robustness_sensitivity": 0.4459, "reproducibility": 0.2242, "problem_framing": 0.4227}}, "optimization": {"n": 725, "n_decided": 551, "accept": 0.3466, "objects": {"empirical_scope": 0.8014, "baselines_ablations": 0.6828, "theory": 0.9269, "method_design": 0.6221, "compute_cost": 0.7103, "clarity": 0.7103, "novelty": 0.3545, "related_work": 0.3834, "stats_metrics": 0.6703, "robustness_sensitivity": 0.5462, "reproducibility": 0.1945, "problem_framing": 0.2455}}, "robotics, autonomy & planning": {"n": 589, "n_decided": 419, "accept": 0.4248, "objects": {"empirical_scope": 0.8896, "baselines_ablations": 0.7606, "theory": 0.6825, "method_design": 0.9185, "compute_cost": 0.7216, "clarity": 0.6333, "novelty": 0.3905, "related_work": 0.3277, "stats_metrics": 0.7046, "robustness_sensitivity": 0.4499, "reproducibility": 0.2733, "problem_framing": 0.2784}}, "transfer / meta / lifelong learning": {"n": 560, "n_decided": 375, "accept": 0.3147, "objects": {"empirical_scope": 0.9071, "baselines_ablations": 0.7964, "theory": 0.8, "method_design": 0.8268, "compute_cost": 0.6929, "clarity": 0.6929, "novelty": 0.4268, "related_work": 0.3839, "stats_metrics": 0.6714, "robustness_sensitivity": 0.5911, "reproducibility": 0.2643, "problem_framing": 0.3214}}, "graphs & geometry": {"n": 528, "n_decided": 367, "accept": 0.3079, "objects": {"empirical_scope": 0.9318, "baselines_ablations": 0.7614, "theory": 0.8655, "method_design": 0.6515, "compute_cost": 0.7159, "clarity": 0.7064, "novelty": 0.3542, "related_work": 0.3788, "stats_metrics": 0.6439, "robustness_sensitivity": 0.4602, "reproducibility": 0.25, "problem_framing": 0.3201}}, "learning theory": {"n": 498, "n_decided": 404, "accept": 0.4653, "objects": {"empirical_scope": 0.7369, "baselines_ablations": 0.4016, "theory": 0.9639, "method_design": 0.6807, "compute_cost": 0.4157, "clarity": 0.757, "novelty": 0.3313, "related_work": 0.3635, "stats_metrics": 0.6084, "robustness_sensitivity": 0.3394, "reproducibility": 0.0964, "problem_framing": 0.2912}}, "learning on time series and dynamical systems": {"n": 457, "n_decided": 330, "accept": 0.303, "objects": {"empirical_scope": 0.9168, "baselines_ablations": 0.814, "theory": 0.86, "method_design": 0.7243, "compute_cost": 0.6718, "clarity": 0.7287, "novelty": 0.3961, "related_work": 0.372, "stats_metrics": 0.7396, "robustness_sensitivity": 0.5908, "reproducibility": 0.267, "problem_framing": 0.302}}, "neuroscience & cognitive science": {"n": 372, "n_decided": 277, "accept": 0.4043, "objects": {"empirical_scope": 0.9409, "baselines_ablations": 0.7097, "theory": 0.7151, "method_design": 0.8817, "compute_cost": 0.4973, "clarity": 0.7849, "novelty": 0.3522, "related_work": 0.3871, "stats_metrics": 0.7419, "robustness_sensitivity": 0.3925, "reproducibility": 0.2527, "problem_framing": 0.3629}}, "probabilistic methods": {"n": 371, "n_decided": 307, "accept": 0.3844, "objects": {"empirical_scope": 0.8814, "baselines_ablations": 0.7143, "theory": 0.9434, "method_design": 0.5687, "compute_cost": 0.6496, "clarity": 0.7385, "novelty": 0.2992, "related_work": 0.4097, "stats_metrics": 0.7655, "robustness_sensitivity": 0.6065, "reproducibility": 0.1968, "problem_framing": 0.31}}, "neurosymbolic & hybrid AI": {"n": 222, "n_decided": 157, "accept": 0.293, "objects": {"empirical_scope": 0.9009, "baselines_ablations": 0.7162, "theory": 0.7703, "method_design": 0.8063, "compute_cost": 0.7477, "clarity": 0.6892, "novelty": 0.3739, "related_work": 0.3964, "stats_metrics": 0.7432, "robustness_sensitivity": 0.536, "reproducibility": 0.3964, "problem_framing": 0.2568}}, "causal reasoning": {"n": 189, "n_decided": 139, "accept": 0.3237, "objects": {"empirical_scope": 0.8783, "baselines_ablations": 0.7354, "theory": 0.9365, "method_design": 0.7302, "compute_cost": 0.5503, "clarity": 0.7831, "novelty": 0.4497, "related_work": 0.4868, "stats_metrics": 0.7143, "robustness_sensitivity": 0.5503, "reproducibility": 0.2328, "problem_framing": 0.3492}}, "infrastructure & systems": {"n": 176, "n_decided": 134, "accept": 0.3284, "objects": {"empirical_scope": 0.892, "baselines_ablations": 0.6989, "theory": 0.5909, "method_design": 0.6818, "compute_cost": 0.8864, "clarity": 0.625, "novelty": 0.4148, "related_work": 0.3295, "stats_metrics": 0.6875, "robustness_sensitivity": 0.4432, "reproducibility": 0.375, "problem_framing": 0.1989}}}}