{"objects": ["baselines_ablations", "clarity", "compute_cost", "empirical_scope", "method_design", "novelty", "problem_framing", "related_work", "reproducibility", "robustness_sensitivity", "stats_metrics", "theory"], "reasonings": ["claim_evidence_match", "confound_hypothesis", "construct_validity", "cost_benefit", "design_justification", "fair_comparison", "merit_recognition", "novelty_standard", "presentation_trust", "reproducibility_norm", "robustness_norm", "statistical_identifiability"], "early": {"baselines_ablations": {"claim_evidence_match": 0.0503, "confound_hypothesis": 0.0181, "construct_validity": 0.0106, "cost_benefit": 0.0263, "design_justification": 0.1513, "fair_comparison": 0.3432, "merit_recognition": 0.1431, "novelty_standard": 0.0782, "presentation_trust": 0.0267, "reproducibility_norm": 0.02, "robustness_norm": 0.0597, "statistical_identifiability": 0.0723}, "clarity": {"claim_evidence_match": 0.0254, "confound_hypothesis": 0.0122, "construct_validity": 0.0184, "cost_benefit": 0.0093, "design_justification": 0.1135, "fair_comparison": 0.0251, "merit_recognition": 0.2177, "novelty_standard": 0.0752, "presentation_trust": 0.3897, "reproducibility_norm": 0.0666, "robustness_norm": 0.0218, "statistical_identifiability": 0.0249}, "compute_cost": {"claim_evidence_match": 0.0539, "confound_hypothesis": 0.0276, "construct_validity": 0.0092, "cost_benefit": 0.259, "design_justification": 0.2143, "fair_comparison": 0.1262, "merit_recognition": 0.0874, "novelty_standard": 0.0611, "presentation_trust": 0.0289, "reproducibility_norm": 0.0276, "robustness_norm": 0.0651, "statistical_identifiability": 0.0394}, "empirical_scope": {"claim_evidence_match": 0.1, "confound_hypothesis": 0.0618, "construct_validity": 0.0202, "cost_benefit": 0.0386, "design_justification": 0.235, "fair_comparison": 0.1121, "merit_recognition": 0.1173, "novelty_standard": 0.098, "presentation_trust": 0.0393, "reproducibility_norm": 0.0348, "robustness_norm": 0.0976, "statistical_identifiability": 0.0454}, "method_design": {"claim_evidence_match": 0.0681, "confound_hypothesis": 0.0601, "construct_validity": 0.01, "cost_benefit": 0.0633, "design_justification": 0.2476, "fair_comparison": 0.0971, "merit_recognition": 0.1311, "novelty_standard": 0.1308, "presentation_trust": 0.0392, "reproducibility_norm": 0.0344, "robustness_norm": 0.0699, "statistical_identifiability": 0.0484}, "novelty": {"claim_evidence_match": 0.0309, "confound_hypothesis": 0.0138, "construct_validity": 0.0046, "cost_benefit": 0.0164, "design_justification": 0.1314, "fair_comparison": 0.0526, "merit_recognition": 0.1097, "novelty_standard": 0.5624, "presentation_trust": 0.0256, "reproducibility_norm": 0.0053, "robustness_norm": 0.0223, "statistical_identifiability": 0.025}, "problem_framing": {"claim_evidence_match": 0.0487, "confound_hypothesis": 0.0277, "construct_validity": 0.0177, "cost_benefit": 0.0343, "design_justification": 0.1814, "fair_comparison": 0.0442, "merit_recognition": 0.2246, "novelty_standard": 0.2168, "presentation_trust": 0.1139, "reproducibility_norm": 0.01, "robustness_norm": 0.0442, "statistical_identifiability": 0.0365}, "related_work": {"claim_evidence_match": 0.0198, "confound_hypothesis": 0.0072, "construct_validity": 0.0108, "cost_benefit": 0.0132, "design_justification": 0.0973, "fair_comparison": 0.0535, "merit_recognition": 0.2156, "novelty_standard": 0.3471, "presentation_trust": 0.1742, "reproducibility_norm": 0.0258, "robustness_norm": 0.0114, "statistical_identifiability": 0.024}, "reproducibility": {"claim_evidence_match": 0.0445, "confound_hypothesis": 0.0278, "construct_validity": 0.0148, "cost_benefit": 0.0538, "design_justification": 0.1243, "fair_comparison": 0.0445, "merit_recognition": 0.1688, "novelty_standard": 0.0686, "presentation_trust": 0.0946, "reproducibility_norm": 0.2894, "robustness_norm": 0.0278, "statistical_identifiability": 0.0408}, "robustness_sensitivity": {"claim_evidence_match": 0.0362, "confound_hypothesis": 0.0544, "construct_validity": 0.0165, "cost_benefit": 0.0473, "design_justification": 0.2057, "fair_comparison": 0.1095, "merit_recognition": 0.0757, "novelty_standard": 0.0544, "presentation_trust": 0.0276, "reproducibility_norm": 0.0725, "robustness_norm": 0.2474, "statistical_identifiability": 0.0528}, "stats_metrics": {"claim_evidence_match": 0.0647, "confound_hypothesis": 0.0264, "construct_validity": 0.1001, "cost_benefit": 0.0344, "design_justification": 0.1304, "fair_comparison": 0.1391, "merit_recognition": 0.1457, "novelty_standard": 0.0765, "presentation_trust": 0.0758, "reproducibility_norm": 0.0376, "robustness_norm": 0.0869, "statistical_identifiability": 0.0824}, "theory": {"claim_evidence_match": 0.0818, "confound_hypothesis": 0.034, "construct_validity": 0.0162, "cost_benefit": 0.0393, "design_justification": 0.2805, "fair_comparison": 0.0583, "merit_recognition": 0.1049, "novelty_standard": 0.1239, "presentation_trust": 0.0742, "reproducibility_norm": 0.0347, "robustness_norm": 0.107, "statistical_identifiability": 0.0454}}, "late": {"baselines_ablations": {"claim_evidence_match": 0.0588, "confound_hypothesis": 0.0248, "construct_validity": 0.0118, "cost_benefit": 0.0289, "design_justification": 0.1574, "fair_comparison": 0.323, "merit_recognition": 0.1645, "novelty_standard": 0.0583, "presentation_trust": 0.0254, "reproducibility_norm": 0.0276, "robustness_norm": 0.0612, "statistical_identifiability": 0.0583}, "clarity": {"claim_evidence_match": 0.0244, "confound_hypothesis": 0.015, "construct_validity": 0.0203, "cost_benefit": 0.0129, "design_justification": 0.132, "fair_comparison": 0.0287, "merit_recognition": 0.2185, "novelty_standard": 0.0571, "presentation_trust": 0.3771, "reproducibility_norm": 0.0725, "robustness_norm": 0.0204, "statistical_identifiability": 0.0209}, "compute_cost": {"claim_evidence_match": 0.051, "confound_hypothesis": 0.0255, "construct_validity": 0.0125, "cost_benefit": 0.3464, "design_justification": 0.1928, "fair_comparison": 0.0961, "merit_recognition": 0.1061, "novelty_standard": 0.0407, "presentation_trust": 0.0178, "reproducibility_norm": 0.0221, "robustness_norm": 0.0551, "statistical_identifiability": 0.0339}, "empirical_scope": {"claim_evidence_match": 0.1348, "confound_hypothesis": 0.0668, "construct_validity": 0.0247, "cost_benefit": 0.0472, "design_justification": 0.2464, "fair_comparison": 0.0868, "merit_recognition": 0.1219, "novelty_standard": 0.0705, "presentation_trust": 0.0294, "reproducibility_norm": 0.0356, "robustness_norm": 0.097, "statistical_identifiability": 0.0389}, "method_design": {"claim_evidence_match": 0.0795, "confound_hypothesis": 0.0669, "construct_validity": 0.017, "cost_benefit": 0.0749, "design_justification": 0.2542, "fair_comparison": 0.077, "merit_recognition": 0.147, "novelty_standard": 0.1039, "presentation_trust": 0.0339, "reproducibility_norm": 0.0315, "robustness_norm": 0.0746, "statistical_identifiability": 0.0395}, "novelty": {"claim_evidence_match": 0.0299, "confound_hypothesis": 0.0181, "construct_validity": 0.0077, "cost_benefit": 0.018, "design_justification": 0.1325, "fair_comparison": 0.0509, "merit_recognition": 0.1067, "novelty_standard": 0.5673, "presentation_trust": 0.0201, "reproducibility_norm": 0.0062, "robustness_norm": 0.0187, "statistical_identifiability": 0.0238}, "problem_framing": {"claim_evidence_match": 0.0497, "confound_hypothesis": 0.0426, "construct_validity": 0.0176, "cost_benefit": 0.0422, "design_justification": 0.18, "fair_comparison": 0.0516, "merit_recognition": 0.3016, "novelty_standard": 0.1538, "presentation_trust": 0.0718, "reproducibility_norm": 0.0128, "robustness_norm": 0.0374, "statistical_identifiability": 0.0387}, "related_work": {"claim_evidence_match": 0.0277, "confound_hypothesis": 0.0214, "construct_validity": 0.0122, "cost_benefit": 0.0145, "design_justification": 0.0998, "fair_comparison": 0.0617, "merit_recognition": 0.2408, "novelty_standard": 0.2858, "presentation_trust": 0.1668, "reproducibility_norm": 0.0239, "robustness_norm": 0.0169, "statistical_identifiability": 0.0285}, "reproducibility": {"claim_evidence_match": 0.0509, "confound_hypothesis": 0.0525, "construct_validity": 0.0161, "cost_benefit": 0.0508, "design_justification": 0.1092, "fair_comparison": 0.0428, "merit_recognition": 0.1303, "novelty_standard": 0.0496, "presentation_trust": 0.0693, "reproducibility_norm": 0.3381, "robustness_norm": 0.0413, "statistical_identifiability": 0.0492}, "robustness_sensitivity": {"claim_evidence_match": 0.0521, "confound_hypothesis": 0.0486, "construct_validity": 0.0204, "cost_benefit": 0.0633, "design_justification": 0.2189, "fair_comparison": 0.08, "merit_recognition": 0.076, "novelty_standard": 0.0409, "presentation_trust": 0.0227, "reproducibility_norm": 0.0533, "robustness_norm": 0.2809, "statistical_identifiability": 0.0429}, "stats_metrics": {"claim_evidence_match": 0.0764, "confound_hypothesis": 0.0429, "construct_validity": 0.1058, "cost_benefit": 0.0412, "design_justification": 0.1498, "fair_comparison": 0.1218, "merit_recognition": 0.1504, "novelty_standard": 0.0526, "presentation_trust": 0.0499, "reproducibility_norm": 0.0381, "robustness_norm": 0.0995, "statistical_identifiability": 0.0716}, "theory": {"claim_evidence_match": 0.0992, "confound_hypothesis": 0.0349, "construct_validity": 0.0178, "cost_benefit": 0.0473, "design_justification": 0.2861, "fair_comparison": 0.0514, "merit_recognition": 0.1286, "novelty_standard": 0.0983, "presentation_trust": 0.0519, "reproducibility_norm": 0.0302, "robustness_norm": 0.1099, "statistical_identifiability": 0.0445}}, "delta": {"baselines_ablations": {"claim_evidence_match": 0.0084, "confound_hypothesis": 0.0067, "construct_validity": 0.0012, "cost_benefit": 0.0026, "design_justification": 0.006, "fair_comparison": -0.0202, "merit_recognition": 0.0214, "novelty_standard": -0.0199, "presentation_trust": -0.0013, "reproducibility_norm": 0.0075, "robustness_norm": 0.0015, "statistical_identifiability": -0.0141}, "clarity": {"claim_evidence_match": -0.001, "confound_hypothesis": 0.0028, "construct_validity": 0.0018, "cost_benefit": 0.0035, "design_justification": 0.0185, "fair_comparison": 0.0036, "merit_recognition": 0.0008, "novelty_standard": -0.0181, "presentation_trust": -0.0126, "reproducibility_norm": 0.0059, "robustness_norm": -0.0014, "statistical_identifiability": -0.004}, "compute_cost": {"claim_evidence_match": -0.0029, "confound_hypothesis": -0.0021, "construct_validity": 0.0033, "cost_benefit": 0.0874, "design_justification": -0.0216, "fair_comparison": -0.0301, "merit_recognition": 0.0187, "novelty_standard": -0.0205, "presentation_trust": -0.0112, "reproducibility_norm": -0.0055, "robustness_norm": -0.01, "statistical_identifiability": -0.0055}, "empirical_scope": {"claim_evidence_match": 0.0348, "confound_hypothesis": 0.0049, "construct_validity": 0.0045, "cost_benefit": 0.0086, "design_justification": 0.0113, "fair_comparison": -0.0253, "merit_recognition": 0.0047, "novelty_standard": -0.0274, "presentation_trust": -0.0099, "reproducibility_norm": 0.0008, "robustness_norm": -0.0006, "statistical_identifiability": -0.0065}, "method_design": {"claim_evidence_match": 0.0114, "confound_hypothesis": 0.0067, "construct_validity": 0.007, "cost_benefit": 0.0117, "design_justification": 0.0065, "fair_comparison": -0.0201, "merit_recognition": 0.0159, "novelty_standard": -0.0269, "presentation_trust": -0.0053, "reproducibility_norm": -0.0028, "robustness_norm": 0.0048, "statistical_identifiability": -0.0089}, "novelty": {"claim_evidence_match": -0.001, "confound_hypothesis": 0.0043, "construct_validity": 0.0031, "cost_benefit": 0.0016, "design_justification": 0.0011, "fair_comparison": -0.0017, "merit_recognition": -0.003, "novelty_standard": 0.0049, "presentation_trust": -0.0055, "reproducibility_norm": 0.0009, "robustness_norm": -0.0036, "statistical_identifiability": -0.0012}, "problem_framing": {"claim_evidence_match": 0.0011, "confound_hypothesis": 0.015, "construct_validity": -0.0001, "cost_benefit": 0.0079, "design_justification": -0.0014, "fair_comparison": 0.0074, "merit_recognition": 0.0771, "novelty_standard": -0.063, "presentation_trust": -0.0421, "reproducibility_norm": 0.0029, "robustness_norm": -0.0069, "statistical_identifiability": 0.0021}, "related_work": {"claim_evidence_match": 0.0079, "confound_hypothesis": 0.0142, "construct_validity": 0.0014, "cost_benefit": 0.0013, "design_justification": 0.0025, "fair_comparison": 0.0082, "merit_recognition": 0.0252, "novelty_standard": -0.0613, "presentation_trust": -0.0074, "reproducibility_norm": -0.0019, "robustness_norm": 0.0055, "statistical_identifiability": 0.0045}, "reproducibility": {"claim_evidence_match": 0.0064, "confound_hypothesis": 0.0247, "construct_validity": 0.0013, "cost_benefit": -0.003, "design_justification": -0.0151, "fair_comparison": -0.0017, "merit_recognition": -0.0386, "novelty_standard": -0.0191, "presentation_trust": -0.0253, "reproducibility_norm": 0.0486, "robustness_norm": 0.0135, "statistical_identifiability": 0.0084}, "robustness_sensitivity": {"claim_evidence_match": 0.0158, "confound_hypothesis": -0.0058, "construct_validity": 0.0039, "cost_benefit": 0.016, "design_justification": 0.0132, "fair_comparison": -0.0295, "merit_recognition": 0.0003, "novelty_standard": -0.0134, "presentation_trust": -0.0049, "reproducibility_norm": -0.0192, "robustness_norm": 0.0335, "statistical_identifiability": -0.0099}, "stats_metrics": {"claim_evidence_match": 0.0117, "confound_hypothesis": 0.0164, "construct_validity": 0.0056, "cost_benefit": 0.0067, "design_justification": 0.0194, "fair_comparison": -0.0173, "merit_recognition": 0.0047, "novelty_standard": -0.0239, "presentation_trust": -0.0259, "reproducibility_norm": 0.0006, "robustness_norm": 0.0126, "statistical_identifiability": -0.0108}, "theory": {"claim_evidence_match": 0.0175, "confound_hypothesis": 0.001, "construct_validity": 0.0015, "cost_benefit": 0.008, "design_justification": 0.0056, "fair_comparison": -0.0069, "merit_recognition": 0.0237, "novelty_standard": -0.0256, "presentation_trust": -0.0223, "reproducibility_norm": -0.0045, "robustness_norm": 0.0029, "statistical_identifiability": -0.0009}}, "floor95": 0.0405, "n_early": 32257, "n_late": 606120}