{"n_pairs": 67290, "soft_base": 0.0597, "word_quartiles": [599, 959, 1532], "moves": [{"key": "disagree", "name": "The contest", "def": "\u201cwe respectfully disagree\u201d \u2014 refusing the objection", "present": 0.0903, "absent": 0.0582, "n": 3301, "prevalence": 0.0491, "delta_by_quartile": [0.023, 0.0162, 0.0284], "delta_by_quartile_all": [0.0143, 0.023, 0.0162, 0.0284], "n_by_quartile": [265, 523, 882, 1631]}, {"key": "clarify", "name": "The clarification", "def": "\u201cto clarify\u201d \u2014 recasting the paper's meaning, not its content", "present": 0.0686, "absent": 0.0557, "n": 21031, "prevalence": 0.3125, "delta_by_quartile": [-0.0021, -0.0026, 0.0053, 0.0082], "delta_by_quartile_all": [-0.0021, -0.0026, 0.0053, 0.0082], "n_by_quartile": [2202, 3977, 5931, 8921]}, {"key": "promise", "name": "The promissory note", "def": "\u201cwe will add\u2026\u201d \u2014 the fix deferred to a future version", "present": 0.0691, "absent": 0.0564, "n": 17674, "prevalence": 0.2627, "delta_by_quartile": [0.0111, 0.0, 0.0005, 0.0163], "delta_by_quartile_all": [0.0111, 0.0, 0.0005, 0.0163], "n_by_quartile": [2807, 3793, 4740, 6334]}, {"key": "concede", "name": "The concession", "def": "\u201cyou are right\u201d \u2014 granting the objection", "present": 0.0674, "absent": 0.0573, "n": 16517, "prevalence": 0.2455, "delta_by_quartile": [-0.0067, 0.0015, -0.0006, 0.0129], "delta_by_quartile_all": [-0.0067, 0.0015, -0.0006, 0.0129], "n_by_quartile": [2220, 3521, 4404, 6372]}, {"key": "gratitude", "name": "The courtesy", "def": "\u201cwe thank the reviewer\u201d \u2014 the ritual register", "present": 0.0605, "absent": 0.0548, "n": 58874, "prevalence": 0.8749, "delta_by_quartile": [0.0011, -0.0029, -0.0135, 0.0141], "delta_by_quartile_all": [0.0011, -0.0029, -0.0135, 0.0141], "n_by_quartile": [13213, 14470, 15259, 15932]}, {"key": "revision", "name": "The amended manuscript", "def": "\u201cin the revised version\u201d \u2014 pointing at a change already made", "present": 0.0631, "absent": 0.0576, "n": 26373, "prevalence": 0.3919, "delta_by_quartile": [-0.0004, -0.0029, -0.0013, 0.0002], "delta_by_quartile_all": [-0.0004, -0.0029, -0.0013, 0.0002], "n_by_quartile": [3978, 5897, 7246, 9252]}, {"key": "new_evidence", "name": "The delivered experiment", "def": "\u201cwe have added new experiments/results\u201d \u2014 evidence produced, not promised", "present": 0.0641, "absent": 0.059, "n": 10060, "prevalence": 0.1495, "delta_by_quartile": [-0.0068, 0.0011, -0.0015, -0.0034], "delta_by_quartile_all": [-0.0068, 0.0011, -0.0015, -0.0034], "n_by_quartile": [1176, 1959, 2747, 4178]}], "effort": [{"decile": 0, "soft": 0.0457, "median_words": 261}, {"decile": 1, "soft": 0.0428, "median_words": 448}, {"decile": 2, "soft": 0.0496, "median_words": 598}, {"decile": 3, "soft": 0.0459, "median_words": 731}, {"decile": 4, "soft": 0.053, "median_words": 871}, {"decile": 5, "soft": 0.0544, "median_words": 1053}, {"decile": 6, "soft": 0.0601, "median_words": 1264}, {"decile": 7, "soft": 0.0723, "median_words": 1532}, {"decile": 8, "soft": 0.0771, "median_words": 1949}, {"decile": 9, "soft": 0.0963, "median_words": 2888}], "evidence_by_object": {"novelty": {"with": 0.0114, "without": 0.0129, "n": 1403}, "empirical_scope": {"with": 0.0167, "without": 0.0118, "n": 5076}, "baselines_ablations": {"with": 0.0104, "without": 0.0117, "n": 3377}, "method_design": {"with": 0.0092, "without": 0.0075, "n": 3247}, "clarity": {"with": 0.008, "without": 0.007, "n": 2372}, "theory": {"with": 0.0129, "without": 0.0162, "n": 3498}, "robustness_sensitivity": {"with": 0.0047, "without": 0.006, "n": 1917}, "related_work": {"with": 0.0182, "without": 0.0145, "n": 933}}}