{"minds": {"k": 5, "min_units": 5, "n_reviewers": 98513, "baseline": {"novelty_standard": 0.1017, "claim_evidence_match": 0.0694, "fair_comparison": 0.0967, "statistical_identifiability": 0.0397, "confound_hypothesis": 0.0402, "design_justification": 0.2072, "robustness_norm": 0.0794, "cost_benefit": 0.061, "construct_validity": 0.0265, "reproducibility_norm": 0.0448, "presentation_trust": 0.0816, "merit_recognition": 0.1519}, "year_totals": {"2018": 1168, "2019": 1977, "2020": 2939, "2021": 4437, "2022": 4368, "2023": 5864, "2024": 13256, "2025": 23580, "2026": 40924}, "clusters": [{"cluster": 1, "reviewers": 22632, "share": 0.2297, "neg_rate": 0.7867, "profile": {"novelty_standard": 0.0636, "claim_evidence_match": 0.0445, "fair_comparison": 0.0544, "statistical_identifiability": 0.0249, "confound_hypothesis": 0.0272, "design_justification": 0.5034, "robustness_norm": 0.0473, "cost_benefit": 0.0436, "construct_validity": 0.0205, "reproducibility_norm": 0.0328, "presentation_trust": 0.0571, "merit_recognition": 0.0805}, "ratio": {"novelty_standard": 0.625, "claim_evidence_match": 0.642, "fair_comparison": 0.562, "statistical_identifiability": 0.628, "confound_hypothesis": 0.677, "design_justification": 2.43, "robustness_norm": 0.596, "cost_benefit": 0.714, "construct_validity": 0.775, "reproducibility_norm": 0.733, "presentation_trust": 0.7, "merit_recognition": 0.53}, "year_counts": {"2018": 269, "2019": 443, "2020": 620, "2021": 1049, "2022": 1022, "2023": 1306, "2024": 2802, "2025": 5429, "2026": 9692}}, {"cluster": 0, "reviewers": 21974, "share": 0.2231, "neg_rate": 0.7966, "profile": {"novelty_standard": 0.0554, "claim_evidence_match": 0.1086, "fair_comparison": 0.0572, "statistical_identifiability": 0.0523, "confound_hypothesis": 0.0754, "design_justification": 0.1222, "robustness_norm": 0.1865, "cost_benefit": 0.0963, "construct_validity": 0.0326, "reproducibility_norm": 0.0533, "presentation_trust": 0.0586, "merit_recognition": 0.1014}, "ratio": {"novelty_standard": 0.545, "claim_evidence_match": 1.566, "fair_comparison": 0.592, "statistical_identifiability": 1.316, "confound_hypothesis": 1.876, "design_justification": 0.59, "robustness_norm": 2.35, "cost_benefit": 1.579, "construct_validity": 1.231, "reproducibility_norm": 1.191, "presentation_trust": 0.719, "merit_recognition": 0.667}, "year_counts": {"2018": 218, "2019": 372, "2020": 576, "2021": 940, "2022": 795, "2023": 1100, "2024": 2582, "2025": 4908, "2026": 10483}}, {"cluster": 2, "reviewers": 19194, "share": 0.1948, "neg_rate": 0.6217, "profile": {"novelty_standard": 0.0737, "claim_evidence_match": 0.0612, "fair_comparison": 0.0548, "statistical_identifiability": 0.0241, "confound_hypothesis": 0.0264, "design_justification": 0.1185, "robustness_norm": 0.059, "cost_benefit": 0.0557, "construct_validity": 0.0207, "reproducibility_norm": 0.0415, "presentation_trust": 0.0624, "merit_recognition": 0.4021}, "ratio": {"novelty_standard": 0.725, "claim_evidence_match": 0.882, "fair_comparison": 0.566, "statistical_identifiability": 0.606, "confound_hypothesis": 0.656, "design_justification": 0.572, "robustness_norm": 0.743, "cost_benefit": 0.913, "construct_validity": 0.781, "reproducibility_norm": 0.927, "presentation_trust": 0.765, "merit_recognition": 2.647}, "year_counts": {"2018": 188, "2019": 315, "2020": 514, "2021": 841, "2022": 840, "2023": 1216, "2024": 2822, "2025": 4576, "2026": 7882}}, {"cluster": 4, "reviewers": 18272, "share": 0.1855, "neg_rate": 0.8471, "profile": {"novelty_standard": 0.2692, "claim_evidence_match": 0.0632, "fair_comparison": 0.0654, "statistical_identifiability": 0.0501, "confound_hypothesis": 0.0315, "design_justification": 0.1004, "robustness_norm": 0.0455, "cost_benefit": 0.0437, "construct_validity": 0.0273, "reproducibility_norm": 0.0461, "presentation_trust": 0.1705, "merit_recognition": 0.087}, "ratio": {"novelty_standard": 2.648, "claim_evidence_match": 0.911, "fair_comparison": 0.676, "statistical_identifiability": 1.262, "confound_hypothesis": 0.784, "design_justification": 0.485, "robustness_norm": 0.573, "cost_benefit": 0.717, "construct_validity": 1.028, "reproducibility_norm": 1.029, "presentation_trust": 2.09, "merit_recognition": 0.573}, "year_counts": {"2018": 295, "2019": 493, "2020": 669, "2021": 864, "2022": 960, "2023": 1269, "2024": 2833, "2025": 4550, "2026": 6339}}, {"cluster": 3, "reviewers": 16441, "share": 0.1669, "neg_rate": 0.8476, "profile": {"novelty_standard": 0.0789, "claim_evidence_match": 0.0724, "fair_comparison": 0.2998, "statistical_identifiability": 0.0557, "confound_hypothesis": 0.0377, "design_justification": 0.1124, "robustness_norm": 0.0441, "cost_benefit": 0.0632, "construct_validity": 0.0304, "reproducibility_norm": 0.0469, "presentation_trust": 0.065, "merit_recognition": 0.0936}, "ratio": {"novelty_standard": 0.776, "claim_evidence_match": 1.044, "fair_comparison": 3.1, "statistical_identifiability": 1.402, "confound_hypothesis": 0.937, "design_justification": 0.542, "robustness_norm": 0.555, "cost_benefit": 1.036, "construct_validity": 1.147, "reproducibility_norm": 1.047, "presentation_trust": 0.797, "merit_recognition": 0.616}, "year_counts": {"2018": 198, "2019": 354, "2020": 560, "2021": 743, "2022": 751, "2023": 973, "2024": 2217, "2025": 4117, "2026": 6528}}]}, "rhetoric": {"overall": {"other": 564239, "generalization": 44499, "counterfactual": 66446, "obligation": 250158, "precedent_comparison": 59685, "alternative_explanation": 24565}, "by_standard": {"merit_recognition": {"other": 117661, "precedent_comparison": 7369, "obligation": 28206, "generalization": 3296, "counterfactual": 2042, "alternative_explanation": 557}, "claim_evidence_match": {"generalization": 21008, "obligation": 21717, "counterfactual": 2321, "other": 22927, "alternative_explanation": 1538, "precedent_comparison": 1801}, "fair_comparison": {"counterfactual": 5851, "other": 39512, "precedent_comparison": 18764, "obligation": 29179, "alternative_explanation": 5139, "generalization": 1425}, "design_justification": {"obligation": 38016, "other": 119868, "precedent_comparison": 7780, "counterfactual": 10850, "alternative_explanation": 6180, "generalization": 10387}, "novelty_standard": {"other": 57785, "obligation": 29836, "precedent_comparison": 15339, "alternative_explanation": 1809, "counterfactual": 10429, "generalization": 1920}, "cost_benefit": {"obligation": 18915, "counterfactual": 3282, "other": 33364, "generalization": 997, "precedent_comparison": 1557, "alternative_explanation": 1271}, "confound_hypothesis": {"generalization": 1039, "other": 23889, "obligation": 8682, "counterfactual": 1971, "precedent_comparison": 925, "alternative_explanation": 2774}, "robustness_norm": {"obligation": 25027, "other": 42004, "counterfactual": 3583, "precedent_comparison": 1572, "generalization": 2508, "alternative_explanation": 3145}, "presentation_trust": {"other": 61859, "generalization": 682, "obligation": 15549, "counterfactual": 2119, "precedent_comparison": 3138, "alternative_explanation": 920}, "reproducibility_norm": {"obligation": 21587, "other": 16759, "counterfactual": 1975, "precedent_comparison": 362, "alternative_explanation": 117, "generalization": 176}, "statistical_identifiability": {"other": 16487, "counterfactual": 20818, "precedent_comparison": 623, "generalization": 680, "obligation": 3354, "alternative_explanation": 424}, "construct_validity": {"other": 12124, "obligation": 10090, "generalization": 381, "alternative_explanation": 691, "counterfactual": 1205, "precedent_comparison": 455}}, "by_valence": {"other": {"positive": 170984, "negative": 371755, "uncertain": 2181, "mixed": 18423, "conditional": 896}, "generalization": {"positive": 7159, "negative": 36039, "mixed": 1121, "uncertain": 120, "conditional": 60}, "counterfactual": {"negative": 62382, "positive": 2974, "mixed": 957, "conditional": 55, "uncertain": 78}, "obligation": {"negative": 240356, "positive": 5761, "mixed": 3404, "conditional": 378, "uncertain": 259}, "precedent_comparison": {"negative": 47397, "positive": 10634, "uncertain": 73, "mixed": 1518, "conditional": 63}, "alternative_explanation": {"negative": 22576, "positive": 1398, "mixed": 479, "uncertain": 76, "conditional": 36}}, "by_year": {"other": {"2018": 6472, "2019": 11801, "2020": 15933, "2021": 24324, "2022": 24823, "2023": 35868, "2024": 79637, "2025": 132379, "2026": 233002}, "generalization": {"2018": 468, "2019": 852, "2020": 1163, "2021": 1766, "2022": 1808, "2023": 2477, "2024": 6039, "2025": 10251, "2026": 19675}, "counterfactual": {"2018": 997, "2019": 1647, "2020": 2282, "2021": 3210, "2022": 3086, "2023": 4408, "2024": 8652, "2025": 14109, "2026": 28055}, "obligation": {"2018": 3430, "2019": 5952, "2020": 8692, "2021": 12334, "2022": 11501, "2023": 15444, "2024": 35348, "2025": 62710, "2026": 94747}, "precedent_comparison": {"2018": 905, "2019": 1509, "2020": 2135, "2021": 3110, "2022": 3157, "2023": 4410, "2024": 8825, "2025": 13535, "2026": 22099}, "alternative_explanation": {"2018": 339, "2019": 486, "2020": 766, "2021": 1075, "2022": 978, "2023": 1458, "2024": 3186, "2025": 5504, "2026": 10773}}}, "vitals": {"2018": {"units_per_reviewer": 4.408, "post_share": 0.0982, "soften_rate": 0.0767, "soften_rate_observed": 0.3815}, "2019": {"units_per_reviewer": 3.988, "post_share": 0.1437, "soften_rate": 0.0645, "soften_rate_observed": 0.3184}, "2020": {"units_per_reviewer": 4.523, "post_share": 0.1166, "soften_rate": 0.0823, "soften_rate_observed": 0.3783}, "2021": {"units_per_reviewer": 4.568, "post_share": 0.1425, "soften_rate": 0.0781, "soften_rate_observed": 0.3659}, "2022": {"units_per_reviewer": 4.527, "post_share": 0.1698, "soften_rate": 0.0591, "soften_rate_observed": 0.284}, "2023": {"units_per_reviewer": 4.358, "post_share": 0.1472, "soften_rate": 0.065, "soften_rate_observed": 0.3093}, "2024": {"units_per_reviewer": 4.43, "post_share": 0.1303, "soften_rate": 0.0462, "soften_rate_observed": 0.2819}, "2025": {"units_per_reviewer": 4.602, "post_share": 0.1561, "soften_rate": 0.0409, "soften_rate_observed": 0.2529}, "2026": {"units_per_reviewer": 4.789, "post_share": 0.106, "soften_rate": 0.0337, "soften_rate_observed": 0.2621}}}