{"dockets": {"clarity": [{"key": "simplicity_law", "name": "The economy rule", "tariff": -0.3558, "se": 0.0346, "n": 841}, {"key": "contribution_clarity", "name": "The contribution rule", "tariff": -0.2898, "se": 0.0224, "n": 1902}, {"key": "notation_law", "name": "The precision rule", "tariff": -0.1443, "se": 0.0275, "n": 1418}, {"key": "evidence_imported", "name": "The evidence rule", "tariff": -0.0774, "se": 0.023, "n": 1845, "adj": -0.0088}, {"key": "verification_clarity", "name": "The verification rule", "tariff": -0.0757, "se": 0.0185, "n": 2971}, {"key": "visualization_law", "name": "The figure rule", "tariff": -0.026, "se": 0.0279, "n": 1271}], "related_work": [{"key": "evidence_imported", "name": "The evidence rule", "tariff": -0.2795, "se": 0.0583, "n": 282, "adj": -0.1937}, {"key": "differentiation", "name": "The differentiation rule", "tariff": -0.2546, "se": 0.0271, "n": 1325}, {"key": "formatting", "name": "The formatting rule", "tariff": -0.2005, "se": 0.0534, "n": 396}, {"key": "citation_accuracy", "name": "The citation rule", "tariff": -0.1411, "se": 0.0493, "n": 420}, {"key": "positioning", "name": "The positioning rule", "tariff": -0.1022, "se": 0.0226, "n": 2157}], "method_design": [{"key": "novelty_rule", "name": "The novelty rule", "tariff": -0.3219, "se": 0.0211, "n": 1970}, {"key": "evidence_imported", "name": "The evidence rule", "tariff": -0.2067, "se": 0.0246, "n": 1546, "adj": -0.1277}, {"key": "justification_rule", "name": "The justification rule", "tariff": -0.1719, "se": 0.0165, "n": 3493}, {"key": "clarity_rule", "name": "The clarity rule", "tariff": -0.1123, "se": 0.0271, "n": 1384}, {"key": "baseline_rule", "name": "The baseline rule", "tariff": -0.0867, "se": 0.0345, "n": 774}, {"key": "robustness_rule", "name": "The robustness rule", "tariff": -0.0596, "se": 0.0171, "n": 3226}, {"key": "reporting_rule", "name": "The reporting rule", "tariff": 0.0538, "se": 0.0373, "n": 671}], "compute_cost": [{"key": "evidence_imported", "name": "The evidence rule", "tariff": -0.1594, "se": 0.0332, "n": 913, "adj": -0.0807}, {"key": "efficiency_validation", "name": "The efficiency-proof rule", "tariff": -0.0913, "se": 0.0202, "n": 2298}, {"key": "scalability", "name": "The scale rule", "tariff": -0.0514, "se": 0.0162, "n": 3605}, {"key": "cost_benefit", "name": "The cost-benefit rule", "tariff": 0.0668, "se": 0.0215, "n": 2094}, {"key": "fair_comparison", "name": "The equal-budget rule", "tariff": 0.0714, "se": 0.0244, "n": 1670}, {"key": "reporting_details", "name": "The disclosure rule", "tariff": 0.1261, "se": 0.0437, "n": 560}], "baselines_ablations": [{"key": "novelty_law", "name": "The non-triviality rule", "tariff": -0.2563, "se": 0.0334, "n": 812}, {"key": "evidence_imported", "name": "The evidence rule", "tariff": -0.2099, "se": 0.0302, "n": 1081, "adj": -0.1564}, {"key": "comparison_law", "name": "The comparison rule", "tariff": -0.1649, "se": 0.01, "n": 9386}, {"key": "ablation_law", "name": "The isolation rule", "tariff": -0.0326, "se": 0.0229, "n": 1813}, {"key": "reporting_details", "name": "The specification rule", "tariff": 0.0084, "se": 0.0478, "n": 440}], "stats_metrics": [{"key": "evidence_imported", "name": "The evidence rule", "tariff": -0.2036, "se": 0.0184, "n": 2850, "adj": -0.1322}, {"key": "baseline_rule", "name": "The baseline rule", "tariff": -0.1754, "se": 0.023, "n": 1734}, {"key": "significance_rule", "name": "The significance rule", "tariff": -0.1642, "se": 0.016, "n": 3866}, {"key": "clarity_rule", "name": "The clarity rule", "tariff": -0.1573, "se": 0.0321, "n": 1032}, {"key": "metric_validity_rule", "name": "The metric-validity rule", "tariff": -0.1248, "se": 0.0282, "n": 1274}, {"key": "validation_rule", "name": "The validation rule", "tariff": -0.0866, "se": 0.0214, "n": 2214}, {"key": "reporting_rule", "name": "The reporting rule", "tariff": 0.0382, "se": 0.0376, "n": 752}], "empirical_scope": [{"key": "novelty_rule", "name": "The novelty rule", "tariff": -0.316, "se": 0.0173, "n": 3055}, {"key": "baseline_rule", "name": "The baseline rule", "tariff": -0.1394, "se": 0.023, "n": 1796}, {"key": "evidence_imported", "name": "The evidence rule", "tariff": -0.1062, "se": 0.0141, "n": 4733, "adj": -0.0623}, {"key": "realism_rule", "name": "The realism rule", "tariff": -0.103, "se": 0.0186, "n": 2852}, {"key": "justification_rule", "name": "The justification rule", "tariff": -0.0918, "se": 0.0195, "n": 2574}, {"key": "breadth_rule", "name": "The breadth rule", "tariff": -0.0724, "se": 0.0137, "n": 5103}, {"key": "reporting_rule", "name": "The reporting rule", "tariff": 0.0154, "se": 0.0281, "n": 1249}], "reproducibility": [{"key": "evidence_imported", "name": "The evidence rule", "tariff": -0.2828, "se": 0.0591, "n": 279, "adj": -0.201}, {"key": "availability", "name": "The availability rule", "tariff": -0.2526, "se": 0.059, "n": 261}, {"key": "validation_rigor", "name": "The validation rule", "tariff": -0.1419, "se": 0.0357, "n": 847}, {"key": "disclosure", "name": "The disclosure rule", "tariff": -0.0707, "se": 0.0248, "n": 1568}, {"key": "provenance_ethics", "name": "The provenance rule", "tariff": -0.0445, "se": 0.0659, "n": 227}, {"key": "code_release", "name": "The code rule", "tariff": 0.0267, "se": 0.0605, "n": 283}], "robustness_sensitivity": [{"key": "novelty_law", "name": "The non-triviality rule", "tariff": -0.3906, "se": 0.0646, "n": 192}, {"key": "comparison_law", "name": "The fair-tuning rule", "tariff": -0.1309, "se": 0.0351, "n": 859}, {"key": "evidence_imported", "name": "The evidence rule", "tariff": -0.1304, "se": 0.0388, "n": 620, "adj": -0.0699}, {"key": "justification_law", "name": "The justification rule", "tariff": -0.0248, "se": 0.0306, "n": 1072}, {"key": "sensitivity_law", "name": "The sensitivity rule", "tariff": 0.0598, "se": 0.0185, "n": 2894}, {"key": "reporting_details", "name": "The specification rule", "tariff": 0.1083, "se": 0.0436, "n": 541}, {"key": "failure_analysis_law", "name": "The failure-analysis rule", "tariff": 0.1551, "se": 0.0594, "n": 327}], "theory": [{"key": "novelty_rule", "name": "The novelty rule", "tariff": -0.2798, "se": 0.0186, "n": 2805}, {"key": "rigor_rule", "name": "The rigor rule", "tariff": -0.2373, "se": 0.0256, "n": 1660}, {"key": "assumption_rule", "name": "The assumption rule", "tariff": -0.2047, "se": 0.0172, "n": 3339}, {"key": "evidence_imported", "name": "The evidence rule", "tariff": -0.1311, "se": 0.0124, "n": 6461, "adj": -0.0727}, {"key": "justification_rule", "name": "The justification rule", "tariff": -0.1294, "se": 0.0381, "n": 662}, {"key": "clarity_rule", "name": "The clarity rule", "tariff": -0.0377, "se": 0.0218, "n": 2228}], "novelty": [{"key": "combination", "name": "The combination rule", "tariff": -0.5043, "se": 0.0179, "n": 2519, "adj": -0.4362}, {"key": "increment", "name": "The increment rule", "tariff": -0.497, "se": 0.0334, "n": 686, "adj": -0.4558}, {"key": "venue", "name": "The venue bar", "tariff": -0.4676, "se": 0.0551, "n": 259, "adj": -0.4479}, {"key": "diff", "name": "The differentiation rule", "tariff": -0.3914, "se": 0.0168, "n": 3130, "adj": -0.331}, {"key": "transfer", "name": "The transfer rule", "tariff": -0.3826, "se": 0.0397, "n": 528, "adj": -0.3313}, {"key": "claims", "name": "The evidence rule (imported)", "tariff": -0.2616, "se": 0.0402, "n": 594, "adj": -0.1926}], "problem_framing": [{"key": "motivation", "name": "The motivation rule", "tariff": -0.4174, "se": 0.0411, "n": 523}, {"key": "evidence_imported", "name": "The evidence rule", "tariff": -0.3439, "se": 0.046, "n": 505, "adj": -0.3004}, {"key": "significance", "name": "The significance rule", "tariff": -0.2962, "se": 0.0459, "n": 455}, {"key": "coherence", "name": "The coherence rule", "tariff": -0.2868, "se": 0.0512, "n": 334}, {"key": "terminology", "name": "The terminology rule", "tariff": -0.2632, "se": 0.0699, "n": 239}, {"key": "justification", "name": "The justification rule", "tariff": -0.2416, "se": 0.0282, "n": 1156}]}, "unit": "std units of that year's rating scale", "min_n": 150, "volume_slopes": {"per_neg_unit": -0.3682, "per_unit": 0.2734}, "evidence_check": {"adj_gap": -0.292, "adj_gap_ci": [-0.381, -0.199], "raw_gap": -0.266, "B": 400}}