{"grammars": {"reviewer": {"n": 952856, "objects": {"stats_metrics": {"share": 0.104, "pos": 0.1727}, "empirical_scope": {"share": 0.1818, "pos": 0.1848}, "clarity": {"share": 0.1016, "pos": 0.2082}, "baselines_ablations": {"share": 0.0903, "pos": 0.1604}, "method_design": {"share": 0.1098, "pos": 0.2141}, "compute_cost": {"share": 0.0712, "pos": 0.1749}, "reproducibility": {"share": 0.0228, "pos": 0.1915}, "theory": {"share": 0.1472, "pos": 0.1703}, "robustness_sensitivity": {"share": 0.0455, "pos": 0.1166}, "novelty": {"share": 0.048, "pos": 0.1848}, "related_work": {"share": 0.0455, "pos": 0.2704}, "problem_framing": {"share": 0.0322, "pos": 0.3726}}}, "ac": {"n": 56736, "objects": {"method_design": {"share": 0.0492, "pos": 0.24}, "theory": {"share": 0.0627, "pos": 0.1694}, "clarity": {"share": 0.0976, "pos": 0.3473}, "related_work": {"share": 0.1567, "pos": 0.3769}, "problem_framing": {"share": 0.0363, "pos": 0.3123}, "empirical_scope": {"share": 0.0702, "pos": 0.2025}, "stats_metrics": {"share": 0.2552, "pos": 0.3407}, "novelty": {"share": 0.092, "pos": 0.2205}, "baselines_ablations": {"share": 0.1043, "pos": 0.309}, "reproducibility": {"share": 0.0181, "pos": 0.2041}, "robustness_sensitivity": {"share": 0.0222, "pos": 0.2079}, "compute_cost": {"share": 0.0355, "pos": 0.2212}}}}, "band": {"lo": 3.5, "hi": 5.0, "n_acc": 1175, "n_rej": 5372}, "forgive": {"baselines_ablations": {"acc": 0.6902, "rej": 0.7187, "adj_delta": -0.0181, "lo": -0.0479, "hi": 0.0082}, "clarity": {"acc": 0.6289, "rej": 0.6845, "adj_delta": -0.0439, "lo": -0.0821, "hi": -0.0109}, "compute_cost": {"acc": 0.6494, "rej": 0.6567, "adj_delta": -0.0075, "lo": -0.04, "hi": 0.0228}, "empirical_scope": {"acc": 0.914, "rej": 0.9127, "adj_delta": 0.0034, "lo": -0.0138, "hi": 0.022}, "method_design": {"acc": 0.7915, "rej": 0.7887, "adj_delta": 0.0021, "lo": -0.026, "hi": 0.0261}, "novelty": {"acc": 0.3532, "rej": 0.3894, "adj_delta": -0.0187, "lo": -0.0442, "hi": 0.0092}, "problem_framing": {"acc": 0.2647, "rej": 0.2969, "adj_delta": -0.025, "lo": -0.0513, "hi": 0.0048}, "related_work": {"acc": 0.3566, "rej": 0.3488, "adj_delta": 0.0306, "lo": -0.0054, "hi": 0.0627}, "reproducibility": {"acc": 0.2698, "rej": 0.2586, "adj_delta": 0.0162, "lo": -0.0123, "hi": 0.0486}, "robustness_sensitivity": {"acc": 0.5319, "rej": 0.5071, "adj_delta": 0.0255, "lo": -0.0066, "hi": 0.0627}, "stats_metrics": {"acc": 0.7311, "rej": 0.758, "adj_delta": -0.0138, "lo": -0.0486, "hi": 0.0144}, "theory": {"acc": 0.726, "rej": 0.7245, "adj_delta": 0.0139, "lo": -0.0134, "hi": 0.0416}}, "redemption": {"acc": {"baselines_ablations": 0.0812, "clarity": 0.06, "compute_cost": 0.0208, "empirical_scope": 0.0319, "method_design": 0.0227, "novelty": 0.0435, "problem_framing": 0.029, "related_work": 0.1683, "reproducibility": 0.0111, "robustness_sensitivity": 0.015, "stats_metrics": 0.2427, "theory": 0.0232}, "rej": {"baselines_ablations": 0.0112, "clarity": 0.0089, "compute_cost": 0.0045, "empirical_scope": 0.0057, "method_design": 0.0026, "novelty": 0.0047, "problem_framing": 0.0037, "related_work": 0.012, "reproducibility": 0.002, "robustness_sensitivity": 0.0022, "stats_metrics": 0.0169, "theory": 0.0039}, "n_units_acc": 2068, "n_units_rej": 10789}}