{"n_reviews_universe": 191946, "n_reviews_with_law": 120540, "laws": [{"docket": "baselines_ablations", "key": "comparison_law", "name": "The comparison rule", "n": 15472}, {"docket": "theory", "key": "evidence_imported", "name": "The evidence rule", "n": 11255}, {"docket": "empirical_scope", "key": "breadth_rule", "name": "The breadth rule", "n": 8047}, {"docket": "empirical_scope", "key": "evidence_imported", "name": "The evidence rule", "n": 7843}, {"docket": "stats_metrics", "key": "significance_rule", "name": "The significance rule", "n": 6412}, {"docket": "theory", "key": "assumption_rule", "name": "The assumption rule", "n": 6409}, {"docket": "method_design", "key": "justification_rule", "name": "The justification rule", "n": 5774}, {"docket": "compute_cost", "key": "scalability", "name": "The scale rule", "n": 5494}, {"docket": "clarity", "key": "verification_clarity", "name": "The verification rule", "n": 5397}, {"docket": "empirical_scope", "key": "novelty_rule", "name": "The novelty rule", "n": 5378}, {"docket": "novelty", "key": "diff", "name": "The differentiation rule", "n": 5207}, {"docket": "theory", "key": "novelty_rule", "name": "The novelty rule", "n": 5204}, {"docket": "method_design", "key": "robustness_rule", "name": "The robustness rule", "n": 5011}, {"docket": "empirical_scope", "key": "realism_rule", "name": "The realism rule", "n": 4556}, {"docket": "stats_metrics", "key": "evidence_imported", "name": "The evidence rule", "n": 4456}, {"docket": "empirical_scope", "key": "justification_rule", "name": "The justification rule", "n": 4418}, {"docket": "robustness_sensitivity", "key": "sensitivity_law", "name": "The sensitivity rule", "n": 4407}, {"docket": "theory", "key": "clarity_rule", "name": "The clarity rule", "n": 4362}, {"docket": "novelty", "key": "combination", "name": "The combination rule", "n": 4251}, {"docket": "related_work", "key": "positioning", "name": "The positioning rule", "n": 3856}, {"docket": "clarity", "key": "contribution_clarity", "name": "The contribution rule", "n": 3489}, {"docket": "theory", "key": "rigor_rule", "name": "The rigor rule", "n": 3478}, {"docket": "compute_cost", "key": "efficiency_validation", "name": "The efficiency-proof rule", "n": 3428}, {"docket": "method_design", "key": "novelty_rule", "name": "The novelty rule", "n": 3361}, {"docket": "stats_metrics", "key": "validation_rule", "name": "The validation rule", "n": 3278}, {"docket": "empirical_scope", "key": "baseline_rule", "name": "The baseline rule", "n": 3257}, {"docket": "clarity", "key": "evidence_imported", "name": "The evidence rule", "n": 3183}, {"docket": "compute_cost", "key": "cost_benefit", "name": "The cost-benefit rule", "n": 2938}, {"docket": "clarity", "key": "notation_law", "name": "The precision rule", "n": 2881}, {"docket": "stats_metrics", "key": "baseline_rule", "name": "The baseline rule", "n": 2827}, {"docket": "baselines_ablations", "key": "ablation_law", "name": "The isolation rule", "n": 2755}, {"docket": "reproducibility", "key": "disclosure", "name": "The disclosure rule", "n": 2547}, {"docket": "compute_cost", "key": "fair_comparison", "name": "The equal-budget rule", "n": 2461}, {"docket": "method_design", "key": "evidence_imported", "name": "The evidence rule", "n": 2430}, {"docket": "related_work", "key": "differentiation", "name": "The differentiation rule", "n": 2346}, {"docket": "method_design", "key": "clarity_rule", "name": "The clarity rule", "n": 2328}, {"docket": "clarity", "key": "visualization_law", "name": "The figure rule", "n": 2274}, {"docket": "empirical_scope", "key": "reporting_rule", "name": "The reporting rule", "n": 2140}, {"docket": "stats_metrics", "key": "metric_validity_rule", "name": "The metric-validity rule", "n": 1950}, {"docket": "problem_framing", "key": "justification", "name": "The justification rule", "n": 1912}, {"docket": "stats_metrics", "key": "clarity_rule", "name": "The clarity rule", "n": 1815}, {"docket": "baselines_ablations", "key": "evidence_imported", "name": "The evidence rule", "n": 1791}, {"docket": "robustness_sensitivity", "key": "justification_law", "name": "The justification rule", "n": 1736}, {"docket": "clarity", "key": "simplicity_law", "name": "The economy rule", "n": 1596}, {"docket": "robustness_sensitivity", "key": "comparison_law", "name": "The fair-tuning rule", "n": 1447}, {"docket": "compute_cost", "key": "evidence_imported", "name": "The evidence rule", "n": 1443}, {"docket": "baselines_ablations", "key": "novelty_law", "name": "The non-triviality rule", "n": 1374}, {"docket": "method_design", "key": "baseline_rule", "name": "The baseline rule", "n": 1364}, {"docket": "reproducibility", "key": "validation_rigor", "name": "The validation rule", "n": 1293}, {"docket": "stats_metrics", "key": "reporting_rule", "name": "The reporting rule", "n": 1208}, {"docket": "theory", "key": "justification_rule", "name": "The justification rule", "n": 1196}, {"docket": "method_design", "key": "reporting_rule", "name": "The reporting rule", "n": 1185}, {"docket": "novelty", "key": "increment", "name": "The increment rule", "n": 1164}, {"docket": "robustness_sensitivity", "key": "evidence_imported", "name": "The evidence rule", "n": 1031}, {"docket": "novelty", "key": "claims", "name": "The evidence rule (imported)", "n": 1026}, {"docket": "robustness_sensitivity", "key": "reporting_details", "name": "The specification rule", "n": 924}, {"docket": "compute_cost", "key": "reporting_details", "name": "The disclosure rule", "n": 918}, {"docket": "problem_framing", "key": "motivation", "name": "The motivation rule", "n": 915}, {"docket": "novelty", "key": "transfer", "name": "The transfer rule", "n": 876}, {"docket": "related_work", "key": "citation_accuracy", "name": "The citation rule", "n": 807}, {"docket": "problem_framing", "key": "evidence_imported", "name": "The evidence rule", "n": 800}], "matrix_laws": [{"docket": "baselines_ablations", "key": "comparison_law", "name": "The comparison rule", "n": 15472}, {"docket": "baselines_ablations", "key": "ablation_law", "name": "The isolation rule", "n": 2755}, {"docket": "baselines_ablations", "key": "evidence_imported", "name": "The evidence rule", "n": 1791}, {"docket": "baselines_ablations", "key": "novelty_law", "name": "The non-triviality rule", "n": 1374}, {"docket": "clarity", "key": "verification_clarity", "name": "The verification rule", "n": 5397}, {"docket": "clarity", "key": "contribution_clarity", "name": "The contribution rule", "n": 3489}, {"docket": "clarity", "key": "evidence_imported", "name": "The evidence rule", "n": 3183}, {"docket": "clarity", "key": "notation_law", "name": "The precision rule", "n": 2881}, {"docket": "clarity", "key": "visualization_law", "name": "The figure rule", "n": 2274}, {"docket": "clarity", "key": "simplicity_law", "name": "The economy rule", "n": 1596}, {"docket": "compute_cost", "key": "scalability", "name": "The scale rule", "n": 5494}, {"docket": "compute_cost", "key": "efficiency_validation", "name": "The efficiency-proof rule", "n": 3428}, {"docket": "compute_cost", "key": "cost_benefit", "name": "The cost-benefit rule", "n": 2938}, {"docket": "compute_cost", "key": "fair_comparison", "name": "The equal-budget rule", "n": 2461}, {"docket": "compute_cost", "key": "evidence_imported", "name": "The evidence rule", "n": 1443}, {"docket": "compute_cost", "key": "reporting_details", "name": "The disclosure rule", "n": 918}, {"docket": "empirical_scope", "key": "breadth_rule", "name": "The breadth rule", "n": 8047}, {"docket": "empirical_scope", "key": "evidence_imported", "name": "The evidence rule", "n": 7843}, {"docket": "empirical_scope", "key": "novelty_rule", "name": "The novelty rule", "n": 5378}, {"docket": "empirical_scope", "key": "realism_rule", "name": "The realism rule", "n": 4556}, {"docket": "empirical_scope", "key": "justification_rule", "name": "The justification rule", "n": 4418}, {"docket": "empirical_scope", "key": "baseline_rule", "name": "The baseline rule", "n": 3257}, {"docket": "empirical_scope", "key": "reporting_rule", "name": "The reporting rule", "n": 2140}, {"docket": "method_design", "key": "justification_rule", "name": "The justification rule", "n": 5774}, {"docket": "method_design", "key": "robustness_rule", "name": "The robustness rule", "n": 5011}, {"docket": "method_design", "key": "novelty_rule", "name": "The novelty rule", "n": 3361}, {"docket": "method_design", "key": "evidence_imported", "name": "The evidence rule", "n": 2430}, {"docket": "method_design", "key": "clarity_rule", "name": "The clarity rule", "n": 2328}, {"docket": "method_design", "key": "baseline_rule", "name": "The baseline rule", "n": 1364}, {"docket": "method_design", "key": "reporting_rule", "name": "The reporting rule", "n": 1185}, {"docket": "novelty", "key": "diff", "name": "The differentiation rule", "n": 5207}, {"docket": "novelty", "key": "combination", "name": "The combination rule", "n": 4251}, {"docket": "novelty", "key": "increment", "name": "The increment rule", "n": 1164}, {"docket": "novelty", "key": "claims", "name": "The evidence rule (imported)", "n": 1026}, {"docket": "novelty", "key": "transfer", "name": "The transfer rule", "n": 876}, {"docket": "problem_framing", "key": "justification", "name": "The justification rule", "n": 1912}, {"docket": "problem_framing", "key": "motivation", "name": "The motivation rule", "n": 915}, {"docket": "problem_framing", "key": "evidence_imported", "name": "The evidence rule", "n": 800}, {"docket": "related_work", "key": "positioning", "name": "The positioning rule", "n": 3856}, {"docket": "related_work", "key": "differentiation", "name": "The differentiation rule", "n": 2346}, {"docket": "related_work", "key": "citation_accuracy", "name": "The citation rule", "n": 807}, {"docket": "reproducibility", "key": "disclosure", "name": "The disclosure rule", "n": 2547}, {"docket": "reproducibility", "key": "validation_rigor", "name": "The validation rule", "n": 1293}, {"docket": "robustness_sensitivity", "key": "sensitivity_law", "name": "The sensitivity rule", "n": 4407}, {"docket": "robustness_sensitivity", "key": "justification_law", "name": "The justification rule", "n": 1736}, {"docket": "robustness_sensitivity", "key": "comparison_law", "name": "The fair-tuning rule", "n": 1447}, {"docket": "robustness_sensitivity", "key": "evidence_imported", "name": "The evidence rule", "n": 1031}, {"docket": "robustness_sensitivity", "key": "reporting_details", "name": "The specification rule", "n": 924}, {"docket": "stats_metrics", "key": "significance_rule", "name": "The significance rule", "n": 6412}, {"docket": "stats_metrics", "key": "evidence_imported", "name": "The evidence rule", "n": 4456}, {"docket": "stats_metrics", "key": "validation_rule", "name": "The validation rule", "n": 3278}, {"docket": "stats_metrics", "key": "baseline_rule", "name": "The baseline rule", "n": 2827}, {"docket": "stats_metrics", "key": "metric_validity_rule", "name": "The metric-validity rule", "n": 1950}, {"docket": "stats_metrics", "key": "clarity_rule", "name": "The clarity rule", "n": 1815}, {"docket": "stats_metrics", "key": "reporting_rule", "name": "The reporting rule", "n": 1208}, {"docket": "theory", "key": "evidence_imported", "name": "The evidence rule", "n": 11255}, {"docket": "theory", "key": "assumption_rule", "name": "The assumption rule", "n": 6409}, {"docket": "theory", "key": "novelty_rule", "name": "The novelty rule", "n": 5204}, {"docket": "theory", "key": "clarity_rule", "name": "The clarity rule", "n": 4362}, {"docket": "theory", "key": "rigor_rule", "name": "The rigor rule", "n": 3478}, {"docket": "theory", "key": "justification_rule", "name": "The justification rule", "n": 1196}], "matrix_cells": [[12, 48, 0.999, 98], [0, 54, 1.181, 115], [51, 55, 1.092, 181], [20, 48, 1.05, 155], [0, 48, 1.209, 625], [0, 60, 1.4, 135], [51, 56, 1.07, 101], [16, 24, 1.304, 274], [22, 24, 1.271, 71], [5, 55, 1.105, 226], [17, 48, 1.042, 273], [30, 48, 1.259, 219], [20, 23, 1.189, 158], [17, 35, 0.909, 71], [0, 25, 1.251, 339], [0, 51, 0.97, 221], [12, 18, 1.008, 83], [23, 55, 0.886, 300], [0, 55, 1.183, 1073], [16, 35, 0.898, 72], [17, 58, 1.29, 230], [5, 10, 0.771, 77], [17, 45, 1.387, 82], [19, 48, 1.209, 184], [16, 48, 1.105, 297], [13, 16, 1.115, 115], [16, 26, 1.041, 106], [13, 38, 1.234, 61], [20, 55, 1.216, 315], [20, 49, 1.199, 123], [4, 27, 1.772, 116], [4, 59, 1.841, 180], [27, 59, 1.731, 73], [6, 23, 0.95, 91], [8, 23, 1.462, 100], [48, 57, 1.03, 179], [23, 50, 1.045, 103], [8, 21, 1.736, 67], [6, 22, 1.719, 61], [6, 59, 1.717, 99], [22, 59, 1.547, 60], [53, 59, 2.25, 74], [2, 4, 1.668, 84], [4, 26, 1.449, 99], [21, 58, 1.243, 92], [18, 56, 0.902, 162], [5, 50, 1.292, 77], [0, 4, 1.37, 596], [0, 35, 1.363, 210], [11, 38, 0.973, 67], [11, 57, 1.044, 97], [38, 57, 1.081, 113], [0, 58, 1.274, 448], [24, 30, 1.023, 139], [8, 38, 1.751, 80], [8, 53, 3.069, 66], [8, 59, 1.99, 82], [38, 59, 1.488, 104], [5, 58, 1.652, 131], [5, 57, 1.142, 108], [8, 16, 1.164, 111], [8, 48, 1.501, 114], [8, 55, 1.485, 198], [16, 55, 0.937, 442], [48, 55, 1.077, 405], [0, 5, 1.191, 335], [0, 42, 1.142, 119], [10, 55, 1.167, 376], [10, 48, 1.112, 204], [49, 57, 1.117, 135], [30, 56, 1.173, 204], [44, 58, 1.8, 71], [0, 18, 1.181, 512], [0, 22, 1.386, 239], [8, 56, 1.027, 78], [23, 56, 0.856, 165], [44, 56, 1.277, 74], [17, 55, 1.17, 538], [18, 55, 0.967, 305], [21, 49, 1.071, 81], [17, 49, 1.329, 242], [18, 49, 0.889, 111], [7, 56, 1.871, 180], [24, 43, 1.243, 143], [5, 51, 1.44, 74], [10, 51, 1.273, 103], [4, 39, 1.395, 92], [27, 30, 1.378, 87], [27, 38, 1.625, 76], [30, 38, 1.348, 141], [0, 10, 1.172, 519], [0, 26, 1.23, 241], [0, 49, 1.278, 459], [26, 49, 1.276, 72], [0, 20, 1.278, 455], [21, 43, 1.097, 82], [2, 18, 1.455, 73], [4, 18, 1.342, 203], [0, 16, 1.141, 740], [4, 55, 1.255, 397], [45, 55, 1.403, 119], [10, 18, 1.072, 165], [50, 56, 0.831, 91], [50, 57, 1.013, 90], [0, 7, 1.27, 295], [0, 30, 1.444, 606], [7, 30, 1.42, 111], [43, 58, 1.118, 112], [4, 23, 1.078, 175], [16, 25, 0.958, 135], [16, 41, 1.189, 127], [2, 5, 1.874, 61], [16, 38, 1.076, 174], [20, 24, 1.196, 138], [32, 55, 0.908, 62], [7, 58, 2.001, 131], [18, 30, 0.775, 113], [18, 53, 1.357, 69], [53, 56, 1.304, 79], [30, 51, 1.643, 126], [4, 48, 1.137, 205], [1, 49, 1.532, 98], [11, 18, 1.031, 99], [18, 57, 1.097, 160], [17, 23, 1.06, 250], [7, 49, 1.615, 108], [0, 15, 1.189, 88], [0, 45, 1.089, 127], [0, 57, 1.125, 472], [0, 56, 1.098, 567], [26, 56, 1.122, 91], [0, 41, 1.52, 312], [4, 20, 1.32, 164], [4, 41, 1.41, 101], [20, 41, 1.382, 81], [24, 56, 0.795, 133], [24, 58, 1.019, 116], [17, 57, 0.992, 211], [11, 16, 1.204, 173], [11, 58, 1.13, 88], [16, 58, 1.072, 196], [7, 17, 1.3, 153], [0, 8, 1.451, 266], [17, 30, 1.062, 226], [18, 58, 1.146, 140], [6, 43, 1.013, 74], [4, 24, 1.164, 164], [5, 23, 1.105, 116], [5, 56, 1.185, 138], [27, 49, 1.369, 74], [25, 49, 1.038, 81], [24, 49, 1.461, 170], [42, 55, 1.187, 90], [19, 55, 0.973, 260], [19, 57, 1.004, 124], [17, 52, 1.519, 121], [31, 55, 0.891, 222], [17, 51, 1.125, 130], [19, 30, 1.27, 157], [19, 56, 0.966, 147], [48, 56, 0.995, 213], [18, 25, 1.211, 114], [0, 9, 0.847, 109], [7, 19, 1.36, 93], [19, 52, 1.534, 71], [5, 16, 0.718, 105], [0, 13, 1.104, 219], [4, 16, 0.994, 225], [4, 56, 1.138, 205], [4, 58, 1.614, 198], [16, 56, 0.815, 219], [8, 41, 2.154, 65], [8, 57, 1.022, 63], [41, 57, 1.086, 75], [10, 58, 1.225, 153], [19, 58, 1.256, 130], [53, 55, 1.438, 153], [21, 55, 1.189, 227], [43, 59, 1.177, 94], [30, 59, 1.335, 126], [6, 50, 1.435, 78], [6, 55, 1.425, 266], [0, 23, 1.231, 573], [5, 30, 1.321, 125], [23, 30, 1.226, 192], [10, 23, 1.029, 170], [6, 19, 1.191, 90], [19, 53, 1.439, 62], [17, 24, 1.377, 282], [18, 24, 0.962, 135], [5, 48, 1.158, 135], [8, 58, 2.477, 128], [48, 58, 1.125, 164], [23, 39, 1.034, 73], [6, 25, 1.184, 66], [19, 38, 1.213, 111], [38, 56, 1.056, 136], [38, 58, 1.426, 125], [41, 58, 1.037, 60], [28, 55, 1.025, 82], [24, 57, 0.861, 117], [5, 18, 1.166, 114], [5, 41, 1.404, 65], [18, 27, 1.426, 93], [18, 41, 1.149, 82], [27, 56, 0.823, 64], [41, 56, 0.858, 73], [33, 55, 1.197, 72], [4, 31, 0.929, 111], [17, 50, 1.015, 136], [23, 31, 0.782, 100], [4, 17, 1.102, 243], [17, 27, 1.314, 125], [0, 27, 1.274, 239], [8, 18, 1.428, 91], [18, 23, 1.069, 173], [27, 55, 1.143, 156], [10, 44, 1.409, 70], [10, 24, 1.332, 191], [7, 55, 2.036, 344], [16, 23, 1.012, 245], [22, 23, 1.289, 83], [0, 6, 1.2, 308], [0, 59, 1.124, 315], [11, 55, 1.184, 238], [17, 31, 0.846, 147], [12, 24, 1.278, 98], [43, 48, 1.094, 161], [16, 30, 0.921, 201], [4, 10, 1.029, 159], [4, 25, 1.429, 135], [10, 25, 1.102, 106], [12, 56, 0.795, 78], [6, 17, 1.43, 186], [13, 17, 1.233, 124], [17, 60, 1.76, 86], [6, 18, 1.424, 127], [7, 18, 1.338, 108], [7, 23, 1.096, 95], [10, 57, 1.0, 149], [5, 43, 0.799, 64], [5, 49, 1.42, 115], [47, 55, 1.366, 74], [43, 49, 1.192, 122], [43, 55, 1.265, 327], [49, 55, 1.175, 307], [41, 55, 1.091, 163], [41, 59, 1.43, 66], [19, 49, 1.078, 114], [17, 38, 1.073, 169], [5, 24, 1.021, 93], [39, 56, 1.047, 82], [6, 27, 1.632, 63], [2, 55, 1.333, 140], [20, 59, 1.212, 97], [18, 59, 0.954, 93], [54, 55, 1.045, 74], [11, 20, 1.191, 94], [38, 41, 1.427, 73], [0, 19, 1.144, 420], [7, 48, 1.257, 121], [18, 48, 1.024, 184], [1, 59, 1.202, 60], [20, 38, 1.161, 103], [17, 39, 1.262, 121], [38, 55, 1.132, 256], [6, 21, 1.537, 83], [0, 38, 1.348, 419], [17, 44, 1.311, 93], [4, 19, 1.35, 173], [4, 44, 1.373, 67], [4, 57, 1.23, 180], [44, 57, 1.275, 60], [38, 49, 1.385, 124], [0, 53, 1.265, 185], [5, 20, 1.208, 97], [25, 56, 0.757, 85], [39, 57, 1.006, 64], [30, 55, 1.137, 347], [17, 54, 1.337, 66], [10, 43, 1.379, 174], [0, 17, 1.163, 735], [0, 43, 1.182, 420], [17, 43, 1.288, 232], [43, 57, 1.046, 125], [5, 25, 1.146, 70], [20, 57, 1.119, 134], [4, 43, 0.993, 123], [1, 16, 1.264, 146], [1, 56, 0.968, 89], [6, 41, 1.515, 64], [19, 24, 1.261, 150], [0, 29, 1.413, 135], [2, 56, 1.187, 71], [2, 58, 1.744, 71], [16, 44, 1.305, 95], [44, 48, 1.086, 63], [5, 59, 1.598, 101], [21, 56, 0.91, 99], [26, 58, 1.34, 74], [12, 49, 0.924, 63], [19, 23, 1.153, 158], [10, 56, 0.976, 179], [6, 20, 1.351, 99], [0, 21, 0.827, 217], [0, 44, 1.208, 169], [18, 51, 1.502, 119], [39, 58, 1.369, 73], [0, 46, 1.288, 107], [46, 55, 1.538, 93], [43, 56, 0.951, 140], [6, 57, 1.275, 110], [18, 26, 1.087, 74], [25, 57, 0.878, 80], [25, 55, 0.913, 180], [16, 57, 0.77, 168], [53, 57, 1.219, 60], [27, 48, 1.402, 109], [21, 23, 1.092, 107], [19, 50, 1.131, 88], [21, 59, 1.068, 63], [38, 51, 1.356, 77], [19, 41, 1.472, 89], [23, 41, 0.979, 75], [0, 39, 1.116, 211], [24, 55, 1.058, 311], [20, 25, 1.073, 83], [21, 57, 1.178, 104], [6, 49, 1.57, 116], [5, 19, 1.304, 108], [19, 59, 0.872, 72], [6, 38, 1.533, 98], [4, 38, 1.513, 164], [26, 48, 1.454, 118], [14, 56, 1.37, 66], [0, 32, 1.29, 121], [21, 30, 1.188, 105], [22, 55, 1.179, 148], [25, 43, 0.778, 60], [10, 49, 0.972, 124], [4, 22, 1.213, 73], [6, 16, 0.952, 127], [17, 53, 1.389, 103], [2, 17, 1.257, 92], [7, 39, 1.761, 62], [7, 53, 2.313, 63], [20, 56, 0.942, 139], [20, 58, 1.564, 157], [9, 55, 0.876, 82], [8, 43, 1.494, 78], [6, 30, 1.17, 101], [1, 10, 1.37, 108], [31, 49, 1.105, 109], [44, 55, 1.601, 163], [19, 39, 1.167, 65], [0, 12, 1.368, 324], [6, 58, 1.77, 128], [31, 58, 0.673, 65], [30, 58, 1.014, 120], [1, 38, 1.102, 61], [23, 52, 1.193, 70], [4, 21, 1.321, 121], [25, 48, 1.015, 114], [0, 24, 1.129, 456], [24, 48, 1.022, 171], [7, 38, 1.952, 113], [0, 14, 1.358, 158], [23, 59, 0.937, 98], [20, 26, 1.198, 67], [26, 55, 1.355, 193], [26, 38, 1.372, 67], [10, 19, 1.012, 132], [17, 56, 0.798, 209], [4, 50, 1.378, 127], [10, 52, 1.165, 65], [4, 30, 1.55, 227], [29, 55, 1.295, 90], [7, 22, 1.868, 60], [41, 49, 1.488, 88], [23, 58, 0.892, 117], [16, 59, 0.748, 109], [41, 48, 1.434, 122], [4, 51, 1.724, 137], [31, 51, 1.15, 72], [13, 48, 1.204, 99], [21, 24, 0.929, 79], [24, 59, 1.035, 94], [16, 51, 1.055, 125], [7, 57, 1.613, 126], [26, 59, 1.385, 61], [17, 25, 1.063, 146], [17, 59, 1.034, 147], [9, 17, 0.92, 60], [38, 43, 1.039, 92], [38, 50, 1.427, 94], [43, 50, 0.97, 73], [21, 48, 1.02, 111], [0, 36, 1.125, 83], [0, 52, 1.304, 205], [26, 57, 1.396, 92], [38, 52, 1.736, 68], [52, 57, 1.286, 68], [39, 55, 1.018, 140], [4, 49, 1.381, 173], [10, 20, 1.408, 178], [10, 38, 1.187, 131], [52, 55, 1.181, 135], [8, 24, 1.162, 69], [24, 31, 0.685, 76], [24, 41, 1.278, 85], [31, 41, 1.312, 74], [1, 55, 1.189, 192], [23, 43, 0.837, 111], [8, 10, 1.122, 73], [10, 22, 1.045, 64], [24, 38, 0.983, 99], [38, 48, 1.351, 174], [7, 24, 1.05, 79], [10, 17, 1.167, 262], [12, 21, 1.224, 61], [49, 56, 1.109, 165], [18, 31, 0.705, 84], [5, 53, 2.091, 69], [16, 31, 0.898, 160], [18, 38, 1.0, 108], [18, 39, 0.989, 65], [30, 35, 1.292, 67], [22, 49, 1.51, 75], [5, 38, 1.869, 131], [30, 52, 1.229, 65], [8, 19, 1.334, 72], [8, 30, 1.135, 70], [16, 39, 0.905, 89], [11, 49, 0.942, 75], [49, 59, 1.065, 86], [45, 48, 1.386, 67], [48, 59, 0.861, 100], [6, 10, 0.999, 91], [25, 38, 0.918, 62], [0, 28, 0.91, 100], [26, 43, 1.129, 63], [16, 45, 1.203, 73], [16, 60, 1.376, 69], [1, 48, 1.076, 99], [2, 48, 1.153, 69], [8, 17, 1.593, 148], [0, 34, 1.416, 100], [0, 50, 1.079, 285], [20, 50, 1.18, 89], [41, 50, 1.747, 76], [1, 19, 1.652, 108], [1, 58, 1.406, 88], [23, 57, 0.818, 128], [10, 27, 1.126, 75], [20, 51, 1.229, 80], [13, 30, 1.123, 75], [5, 17, 0.996, 142], [51, 59, 1.288, 66], [30, 43, 0.878, 105], [21, 38, 1.039, 68], [23, 51, 1.27, 108], [16, 43, 1.283, 237], [17, 42, 1.249, 66], [14, 16, 1.174, 71], [31, 57, 0.703, 81], [23, 48, 0.98, 189], [10, 16, 1.146, 264], [10, 30, 1.147, 171], [11, 19, 1.118, 91], [1, 17, 1.253, 141], [20, 30, 1.143, 137], [0, 40, 1.245, 81], [21, 25, 1.21, 69], [6, 56, 1.223, 130], [50, 55, 0.916, 176], [0, 47, 1.41, 105], [49, 58, 1.205, 122], [7, 59, 3.64, 190], [17, 29, 1.384, 67], [51, 57, 1.2, 92], [23, 49, 1.037, 139], [27, 58, 1.437, 76], [53, 58, 1.915, 79], [30, 41, 1.664, 115], [5, 31, 0.906, 70], [35, 48, 1.08, 69], [7, 20, 1.342, 89], [23, 38, 1.207, 140], [8, 49, 1.402, 74], [22, 38, 1.652, 71], [1, 4, 1.472, 114], [1, 23, 1.062, 88], [7, 10, 1.237, 102], [4, 13, 0.983, 68], [4, 53, 1.685, 86], [13, 23, 1.162, 86], [13, 55, 1.019, 147], [10, 53, 1.155, 60], [10, 59, 1.025, 102], [17, 41, 1.316, 137], [41, 51, 1.653, 62], [39, 48, 1.021, 80], [7, 43, 1.073, 71], [20, 43, 1.075, 109], [0, 11, 1.397, 386], [11, 56, 0.813, 93], [17, 28, 1.22, 68], [12, 23, 0.996, 88], [0, 31, 1.173, 402], [1, 18, 1.218, 94], [18, 43, 0.996, 123], [22, 48, 1.259, 90], [8, 20, 1.815, 95], [40, 55, 1.543, 73], [2, 16, 0.959, 72], [31, 43, 0.83, 81], [13, 19, 1.215, 71], [31, 56, 0.747, 106], [7, 16, 0.778, 94], [3, 55, 0.77, 62], [12, 50, 1.515, 76], [30, 57, 0.815, 115], [1, 31, 1.409, 86], [18, 52, 1.354, 74], [1, 50, 1.424, 67], [15, 55, 1.208, 65], [6, 24, 1.119, 93], [16, 27, 0.973, 95], [31, 48, 0.944, 134], [2, 23, 1.151, 62], [11, 23, 1.047, 108], [12, 55, 1.173, 202], [23, 35, 1.13, 65], [20, 52, 1.493, 67], [31, 38, 0.948, 81], [10, 31, 1.06, 129], [31, 50, 1.198, 87], [30, 49, 1.506, 182], [10, 50, 1.087, 102], [43, 51, 1.202, 78], [2, 38, 1.723, 62], [11, 30, 1.065, 99], [10, 21, 1.276, 119], [19, 25, 1.04, 83], [25, 58, 0.943, 72], [16, 49, 0.98, 183], [11, 21, 1.135, 66], [51, 58, 1.245, 80], [4, 12, 1.053, 87], [12, 16, 1.518, 187], [39, 49, 1.102, 60], [10, 35, 1.133, 62], [7, 41, 1.857, 71], [12, 57, 1.029, 82], [20, 31, 0.767, 75], [30, 50, 1.349, 120], [16, 53, 0.999, 76], [2, 30, 1.4, 68], [13, 56, 0.949, 78], [19, 43, 1.109, 116], [19, 31, 1.11, 112], [17, 26, 1.209, 120], [16, 42, 1.384, 75], [1, 6, 1.423, 65], [1, 24, 1.084, 78], [24, 51, 1.057, 78], [1, 20, 1.467, 93], [22, 58, 1.254, 61], [18, 50, 0.893, 82], [22, 30, 1.171, 68], [20, 27, 1.642, 88], [16, 52, 1.419, 116], [4, 52, 1.404, 77], [6, 48, 1.288, 137], [4, 14, 1.503, 61], [19, 51, 1.267, 85], [13, 24, 1.23, 79], [0, 33, 1.209, 100], [1, 30, 1.673, 125], [10, 41, 1.139, 83], [12, 58, 1.108, 74], [13, 43, 1.327, 75], [10, 26, 1.165, 81], [14, 48, 1.307, 63], [11, 48, 0.987, 113], [11, 17, 1.021, 143], [12, 19, 1.219, 85], [12, 17, 1.158, 139], [12, 20, 1.227, 83], [11, 31, 1.054, 80], [10, 39, 1.102, 74], [1, 51, 1.602, 65], [12, 31, 1.122, 73], [14, 55, 1.336, 113], [24, 35, 1.322, 66], [25, 30, 0.658, 60], [41, 43, 1.146, 67], [1, 57, 1.017, 76], [16, 50, 1.092, 150], [35, 55, 0.83, 93], [12, 30, 1.054, 84], [12, 43, 1.423, 96], [1, 8, 2.451, 80], [13, 58, 1.144, 64], [0, 37, 1.256, 81], [1, 11, 1.728, 85], [4, 11, 1.017, 98], [11, 43, 1.016, 80], [24, 50, 1.18, 101], [1, 43, 1.265, 80], [26, 30, 1.062, 70], [1, 12, 1.707, 72], [11, 24, 0.905, 81]], "top_cross": [{"a": {"docket": "clarity", "key": "notation_law", "name": "The precision rule"}, "b": {"docket": "theory", "key": "rigor_rule", "name": "The rigor rule"}, "joint": 190, "lift": 3.64, "cross": true, "lift_cross": 2.113, "ci_lo": 2.938, "ci_hi": 3.901, "lift_cross_yr": 2.003}, {"a": {"docket": "clarity", "key": "visualization_law", "name": "The figure rule"}, "b": {"docket": "stats_metrics", "key": "clarity_rule", "name": "The clarity rule"}, "joint": 66, "lift": 3.069, "cross": true, "lift_cross": 1.812, "ci_lo": 2.294, "ci_hi": 3.595, "lift_cross_yr": 1.78}, {"a": {"docket": "clarity", "key": "visualization_law", "name": "The figure rule"}, "b": {"docket": "theory", "key": "clarity_rule", "name": "The clarity rule"}, "joint": 128, "lift": 2.477, "cross": true, "lift_cross": 1.68, "ci_lo": 1.937, "ci_hi": 2.728, "lift_cross_yr": 1.662}, {"a": {"docket": "baselines_ablations", "key": "ablation_law", "name": "The isolation rule"}, "b": {"docket": "clarity", "key": "visualization_law", "name": "The figure rule"}, "joint": 80, "lift": 2.451, "cross": true, "lift_cross": 1.566, "ci_lo": 1.844, "ci_hi": 2.786, "lift_cross_yr": 1.578}, {"a": {"docket": "clarity", "key": "notation_law", "name": "The precision rule"}, "b": {"docket": "stats_metrics", "key": "clarity_rule", "name": "The clarity rule"}, "joint": 63, "lift": 2.313, "cross": true, "lift_cross": 1.586, "ci_lo": 1.669, "ci_hi": 2.726, "lift_cross_yr": 1.561}, {"a": {"docket": "stats_metrics", "key": "clarity_rule", "name": "The clarity rule"}, "b": {"docket": "theory", "key": "rigor_rule", "name": "The rigor rule"}, "joint": 74, "lift": 2.25, "cross": true, "lift_cross": 1.618, "ci_lo": 1.675, "ci_hi": 2.588, "lift_cross_yr": 1.592}, {"a": {"docket": "clarity", "key": "visualization_law", "name": "The figure rule"}, "b": {"docket": "reproducibility", "key": "disclosure", "name": "The disclosure rule"}, "joint": 65, "lift": 2.154, "cross": true, "lift_cross": 1.331, "ci_lo": 1.548, "ci_hi": 2.506, "lift_cross_yr": 1.336}, {"a": {"docket": "clarity", "key": "contribution_clarity", "name": "The contribution rule"}, "b": {"docket": "stats_metrics", "key": "clarity_rule", "name": "The clarity rule"}, "joint": 69, "lift": 2.091, "cross": true, "lift_cross": 1.457, "ci_lo": 1.499, "ci_hi": 2.38, "lift_cross_yr": 1.431}, {"a": {"docket": "clarity", "key": "notation_law", "name": "The precision rule"}, "b": {"docket": "theory", "key": "evidence_imported", "name": "The evidence rule"}, "joint": 344, "lift": 2.036, "cross": true, "lift_cross": 1.551, "ci_lo": 1.747, "ci_hi": 2.098, "lift_cross_yr": 1.555}, {"a": {"docket": "clarity", "key": "notation_law", "name": "The precision rule"}, "b": {"docket": "theory", "key": "clarity_rule", "name": "The clarity rule"}, "joint": 131, "lift": 2.001, "cross": true, "lift_cross": 1.673, "ci_lo": 1.625, "ci_hi": 2.183, "lift_cross_yr": 1.617}, {"a": {"docket": "clarity", "key": "visualization_law", "name": "The figure rule"}, "b": {"docket": "theory", "key": "rigor_rule", "name": "The rigor rule"}, "joint": 82, "lift": 1.99, "cross": true, "lift_cross": 1.572, "ci_lo": 1.491, "ci_hi": 2.257, "lift_cross_yr": 1.547}, {"a": {"docket": "clarity", "key": "notation_law", "name": "The precision rule"}, "b": {"docket": "related_work", "key": "positioning", "name": "The positioning rule"}, "joint": 113, "lift": 1.952, "cross": true, "lift_cross": 1.527, "ci_lo": 1.49, "ci_hi": 2.179, "lift_cross_yr": 1.514}, {"a": {"docket": "stats_metrics", "key": "clarity_rule", "name": "The clarity rule"}, "b": {"docket": "theory", "key": "clarity_rule", "name": "The clarity rule"}, "joint": 79, "lift": 1.915, "cross": true, "lift_cross": 1.395, "ci_lo": 1.419, "ci_hi": 2.188, "lift_cross_yr": 1.379}, {"a": {"docket": "baselines_ablations", "key": "evidence_imported", "name": "The evidence rule"}, "b": {"docket": "clarity", "key": "contribution_clarity", "name": "The contribution rule"}, "joint": 61, "lift": 1.874, "cross": true, "lift_cross": 1.265, "ci_lo": 1.402, "ci_hi": 2.227, "lift_cross_yr": 1.264}, {"a": {"docket": "clarity", "key": "notation_law", "name": "The precision rule"}, "b": {"docket": "theory", "key": "assumption_rule", "name": "The assumption rule"}, "joint": 180, "lift": 1.871, "cross": true, "lift_cross": 1.412, "ci_lo": 1.504, "ci_hi": 1.982, "lift_cross_yr": 1.385}, {"a": {"docket": "clarity", "key": "contribution_clarity", "name": "The contribution rule"}, "b": {"docket": "related_work", "key": "positioning", "name": "The positioning rule"}, "joint": 131, "lift": 1.869, "cross": true, "lift_cross": 1.42, "ci_lo": 1.459, "ci_hi": 2.064, "lift_cross_yr": 1.409}, {"a": {"docket": "clarity", "key": "notation_law", "name": "The precision rule"}, "b": {"docket": "empirical_scope", "key": "reporting_rule", "name": "The reporting rule"}, "joint": 60, "lift": 1.868, "cross": true, "lift_cross": 1.328, "ci_lo": 1.315, "ci_hi": 2.188, "lift_cross_yr": 1.318}, {"a": {"docket": "clarity", "key": "notation_law", "name": "The precision rule"}, "b": {"docket": "reproducibility", "key": "disclosure", "name": "The disclosure rule"}, "joint": 71, "lift": 1.857, "cross": true, "lift_cross": 1.336, "ci_lo": 1.378, "ci_hi": 2.141, "lift_cross_yr": 1.365}, {"a": {"docket": "clarity", "key": "verification_clarity", "name": "The verification rule"}, "b": {"docket": "theory", "key": "rigor_rule", "name": "The rigor rule"}, "joint": 180, "lift": 1.841, "cross": true, "lift_cross": 1.528, "ci_lo": 1.502, "ci_hi": 1.986, "lift_cross_yr": 1.489}, {"a": {"docket": "clarity", "key": "visualization_law", "name": "The figure rule"}, "b": {"docket": "empirical_scope", "key": "justification_rule", "name": "The justification rule"}, "joint": 95, "lift": 1.815, "cross": true, "lift_cross": 1.518, "ci_lo": 1.38, "ci_hi": 2.052, "lift_cross_yr": 1.506}, {"a": {"docket": "robustness_sensitivity", "key": "justification_law", "name": "The justification rule"}, "b": {"docket": "theory", "key": "clarity_rule", "name": "The clarity rule"}, "joint": 71, "lift": 1.8, "cross": true, "lift_cross": 1.408, "ci_lo": 1.36, "ci_hi": 2.073, "lift_cross_yr": 1.423}, {"a": {"docket": "clarity", "key": "verification_clarity", "name": "The verification rule"}, "b": {"docket": "method_design", "key": "clarity_rule", "name": "The clarity rule"}, "joint": 116, "lift": 1.772, "cross": true, "lift_cross": 1.402, "ci_lo": 1.361, "ci_hi": 1.935, "lift_cross_yr": 1.388}, {"a": {"docket": "clarity", "key": "evidence_imported", "name": "The evidence rule"}, "b": {"docket": "theory", "key": "clarity_rule", "name": "The clarity rule"}, "joint": 128, "lift": 1.77, "cross": true, "lift_cross": 1.201, "ci_lo": 1.374, "ci_hi": 1.966, "lift_cross_yr": 1.197}, {"a": {"docket": "clarity", "key": "notation_law", "name": "The precision rule"}, "b": {"docket": "related_work", "key": "differentiation", "name": "The differentiation rule"}, "joint": 62, "lift": 1.761, "cross": true, "lift_cross": 1.308, "ci_lo": 1.272, "ci_hi": 2.048, "lift_cross_yr": 1.301}, {"a": {"docket": "empirical_scope", "key": "evidence_imported", "name": "The evidence rule"}, "b": {"docket": "theory", "key": "justification_rule", "name": "The justification rule"}, "joint": 86, "lift": 1.76, "cross": true, "lift_cross": 1.328, "ci_lo": 1.327, "ci_hi": 2.057, "lift_cross_yr": 1.331}, {"a": {"docket": "clarity", "key": "visualization_law", "name": "The figure rule"}, "b": {"docket": "related_work", "key": "positioning", "name": "The positioning rule"}, "joint": 80, "lift": 1.751, "cross": true, "lift_cross": 1.701, "ci_lo": 1.266, "ci_hi": 2.023, "lift_cross_yr": 1.689}, {"a": {"docket": "reproducibility", "key": "disclosure", "name": "The disclosure rule"}, "b": {"docket": "stats_metrics", "key": "validation_rule", "name": "The validation rule"}, "joint": 76, "lift": 1.747, "cross": true, "lift_cross": 1.397, "ci_lo": 1.31, "ci_hi": 2.004, "lift_cross_yr": 1.367}, {"a": {"docket": "baselines_ablations", "key": "evidence_imported", "name": "The evidence rule"}, "b": {"docket": "theory", "key": "clarity_rule", "name": "The clarity rule"}, "joint": 71, "lift": 1.744, "cross": true, "lift_cross": 1.28, "ci_lo": 1.327, "ci_hi": 1.992, "lift_cross_yr": 1.29}, {"a": {"docket": "clarity", "key": "visualization_law", "name": "The figure rule"}, "b": {"docket": "empirical_scope", "key": "baseline_rule", "name": "The baseline rule"}, "joint": 67, "lift": 1.736, "cross": true, "lift_cross": 1.522, "ci_lo": 1.249, "ci_hi": 2.011, "lift_cross_yr": 1.499}, {"a": {"docket": "related_work", "key": "positioning", "name": "The positioning rule"}, "b": {"docket": "stats_metrics", "key": "metric_validity_rule", "name": "The metric-validity rule"}, "joint": 68, "lift": 1.736, "cross": true, "lift_cross": 1.264, "ci_lo": 1.27, "ci_hi": 2.036, "lift_cross_yr": 1.266}], "bottom_cross": [{"a": {"docket": "method_design", "key": "novelty_rule", "name": "The novelty rule"}, "b": {"docket": "novelty", "key": "diff", "name": "The differentiation rule"}, "joint": 60, "lift": 0.658, "cross": true, "lift_cross": 1.179, "ci_lo": 0.466, "ci_hi": 0.794, "lift_cross_yr": 1.176}, {"a": {"docket": "novelty", "key": "combination", "name": "The combination rule"}, "b": {"docket": "theory", "key": "clarity_rule", "name": "The clarity rule"}, "joint": 65, "lift": 0.673, "cross": true, "lift_cross": 0.942, "ci_lo": 0.48, "ci_hi": 0.778, "lift_cross_yr": 0.956}, {"a": {"docket": "method_design", "key": "robustness_rule", "name": "The robustness rule"}, "b": {"docket": "novelty", "key": "combination", "name": "The combination rule"}, "joint": 76, "lift": 0.685, "cross": true, "lift_cross": 1.061, "ci_lo": 0.518, "ci_hi": 0.785, "lift_cross_yr": 1.05}, {"a": {"docket": "novelty", "key": "combination", "name": "The combination rule"}, "b": {"docket": "theory", "key": "novelty_rule", "name": "The novelty rule"}, "joint": 81, "lift": 0.703, "cross": true, "lift_cross": 0.862, "ci_lo": 0.514, "ci_hi": 0.817, "lift_cross_yr": 0.868}, {"a": {"docket": "empirical_scope", "key": "novelty_rule", "name": "The novelty rule"}, "b": {"docket": "novelty", "key": "combination", "name": "The combination rule"}, "joint": 84, "lift": 0.705, "cross": true, "lift_cross": 1.106, "ci_lo": 0.518, "ci_hi": 0.804, "lift_cross_yr": 1.112}, {"a": {"docket": "clarity", "key": "contribution_clarity", "name": "The contribution rule"}, "b": {"docket": "empirical_scope", "key": "breadth_rule", "name": "The breadth rule"}, "joint": 105, "lift": 0.718, "cross": true, "lift_cross": 0.975, "ci_lo": 0.543, "ci_hi": 0.82, "lift_cross_yr": 0.983}, {"a": {"docket": "novelty", "key": "combination", "name": "The combination rule"}, "b": {"docket": "theory", "key": "assumption_rule", "name": "The assumption rule"}, "joint": 106, "lift": 0.747, "cross": true, "lift_cross": 0.898, "ci_lo": 0.577, "ci_hi": 0.832, "lift_cross_yr": 0.906}, {"a": {"docket": "empirical_scope", "key": "breadth_rule", "name": "The breadth rule"}, "b": {"docket": "theory", "key": "rigor_rule", "name": "The rigor rule"}, "joint": 109, "lift": 0.748, "cross": true, "lift_cross": 0.903, "ci_lo": 0.588, "ci_hi": 0.827, "lift_cross_yr": 0.933}, {"a": {"docket": "method_design", "key": "novelty_rule", "name": "The novelty rule"}, "b": {"docket": "theory", "key": "assumption_rule", "name": "The assumption rule"}, "joint": 85, "lift": 0.757, "cross": true, "lift_cross": 0.905, "ci_lo": 0.579, "ci_hi": 0.857, "lift_cross_yr": 0.91}, {"a": {"docket": "empirical_scope", "key": "justification_rule", "name": "The justification rule"}, "b": {"docket": "novelty", "key": "combination", "name": "The combination rule"}, "joint": 75, "lift": 0.767, "cross": true, "lift_cross": 1.047, "ci_lo": 0.561, "ci_hi": 0.884, "lift_cross_yr": 1.047}, {"a": {"docket": "empirical_scope", "key": "breadth_rule", "name": "The breadth rule"}, "b": {"docket": "theory", "key": "novelty_rule", "name": "The novelty rule"}, "joint": 168, "lift": 0.77, "cross": true, "lift_cross": 0.937, "ci_lo": 0.622, "ci_hi": 0.833, "lift_cross_yr": 0.948}, {"a": {"docket": "baselines_ablations", "key": "novelty_law", "name": "The non-triviality rule"}, "b": {"docket": "theory", "key": "evidence_imported", "name": "The evidence rule"}, "joint": 62, "lift": 0.77, "cross": true, "lift_cross": 0.954, "ci_lo": 0.542, "ci_hi": 0.898, "lift_cross_yr": 0.957}, {"a": {"docket": "clarity", "key": "contribution_clarity", "name": "The contribution rule"}, "b": {"docket": "compute_cost", "key": "scalability", "name": "The scale rule"}, "joint": 77, "lift": 0.771, "cross": true, "lift_cross": 1.168, "ci_lo": 0.581, "ci_hi": 0.879, "lift_cross_yr": 1.185}, {"a": {"docket": "empirical_scope", "key": "novelty_rule", "name": "The novelty rule"}, "b": {"docket": "novelty", "key": "diff", "name": "The differentiation rule"}, "joint": 113, "lift": 0.775, "cross": true, "lift_cross": 1.199, "ci_lo": 0.609, "ci_hi": 0.865, "lift_cross_yr": 1.193}, {"a": {"docket": "method_design", "key": "novelty_rule", "name": "The novelty rule"}, "b": {"docket": "robustness_sensitivity", "key": "sensitivity_law", "name": "The sensitivity rule"}, "joint": 60, "lift": 0.778, "cross": true, "lift_cross": 1.118, "ci_lo": 0.546, "ci_hi": 0.912, "lift_cross_yr": 1.113}], "top_same": [{"a": {"docket": "clarity", "key": "contribution_clarity", "name": "The contribution rule"}, "b": {"docket": "clarity", "key": "simplicity_law", "name": "The economy rule"}, "joint": 117, "lift": 4.033, "cross": false}, {"a": {"docket": "theory", "key": "assumption_rule", "name": "The assumption rule"}, "b": {"docket": "theory", "key": "rigor_rule", "name": "The rigor rule"}, "joint": 404, "lift": 3.479, "cross": false}, {"a": {"docket": "clarity", "key": "notation_law", "name": "The precision rule"}, "b": {"docket": "clarity", "key": "visualization_law", "name": "The figure rule"}, "joint": 117, "lift": 3.428, "cross": false}, {"a": {"docket": "theory", "key": "clarity_rule", "name": "The clarity rule"}, "b": {"docket": "theory", "key": "rigor_rule", "name": "The rigor rule"}, "joint": 253, "lift": 3.201, "cross": false}, {"a": {"docket": "clarity", "key": "evidence_imported", "name": "The evidence rule"}, "b": {"docket": "clarity", "key": "simplicity_law", "name": "The economy rule"}, "joint": 83, "lift": 3.136, "cross": false}, {"a": {"docket": "method_design", "key": "evidence_imported", "name": "The evidence rule"}, "b": {"docket": "method_design", "key": "novelty_rule", "name": "The novelty rule"}, "joint": 120, "lift": 2.82, "cross": false}, {"a": {"docket": "theory", "key": "novelty_rule", "name": "The novelty rule"}, "b": {"docket": "theory", "key": "rigor_rule", "name": "The rigor rule"}, "joint": 262, "lift": 2.779, "cross": false}, {"a": {"docket": "theory", "key": "evidence_imported", "name": "The evidence rule"}, "b": {"docket": "theory", "key": "rigor_rule", "name": "The rigor rule"}, "joint": 559, "lift": 2.741, "cross": false}, {"a": {"docket": "method_design", "key": "clarity_rule", "name": "The clarity rule"}, "b": {"docket": "method_design", "key": "novelty_rule", "name": "The novelty rule"}, "joint": 107, "lift": 2.625, "cross": false}, {"a": {"docket": "novelty", "key": "claims", "name": "The evidence rule (imported)"}, "b": {"docket": "novelty", "key": "diff", "name": "The differentiation rule"}, "joint": 73, "lift": 2.623, "cross": false}, {"a": {"docket": "theory", "key": "clarity_rule", "name": "The clarity rule"}, "b": {"docket": "theory", "key": "justification_rule", "name": "The justification rule"}, "joint": 69, "lift": 2.539, "cross": false}, {"a": {"docket": "clarity", "key": "contribution_clarity", "name": "The contribution rule"}, "b": {"docket": "clarity", "key": "visualization_law", "name": "The figure rule"}, "joint": 101, "lift": 2.443, "cross": false}, {"a": {"docket": "clarity", "key": "evidence_imported", "name": "The evidence rule"}, "b": {"docket": "clarity", "key": "visualization_law", "name": "The figure rule"}, "joint": 90, "lift": 2.387, "cross": false}, {"a": {"docket": "empirical_scope", "key": "justification_rule", "name": "The justification rule"}, "b": {"docket": "empirical_scope", "key": "reporting_rule", "name": "The reporting rule"}, "joint": 116, "lift": 2.355, "cross": false}, {"a": {"docket": "method_design", "key": "clarity_rule", "name": "The clarity rule"}, "b": {"docket": "method_design", "key": "evidence_imported", "name": "The evidence rule"}, "joint": 69, "lift": 2.341, "cross": false}], "min_joint": 60}