{"n": 293671, "thresholds": [0.85, 0.9, 0.95], "overall": [0.1986, 0.0378, 0.0056], "median_sim": 0.8114, "hist": {"bins": [0.5, 0.51, 0.52, 0.53, 0.54, 0.55, 0.56, 0.57, 0.58, 0.59, 0.6, 0.61, 0.62, 0.63, 0.64, 0.65, 0.66, 0.67, 0.68, 0.69, 0.7, 0.71, 0.72, 0.73, 0.74, 0.75, 0.76, 0.77, 0.78, 0.79, 0.8, 0.81, 0.82, 0.83, 0.84, 0.85, 0.86, 0.87, 0.88, 0.89, 0.9, 0.91, 0.92, 0.93, 0.94, 0.95, 0.96, 0.97, 0.98, 0.99], "counts": [0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 1, 2, 4, 6, 8, 22, 46, 89, 188, 343, 601, 992, 1699, 2662, 3963, 6017, 8649, 11683, 15167, 18454, 21837, 24593, 26074, 26100, 24911, 22430, 18817, 15353, 11757, 8877, 6543, 4686, 3380, 2360, 1636, 1201, 870, 599, 395, 282, 174, 141]}, "by_object": {"clarity": {"n": 26192, "shares": [0.335, 0.0801, 0.0137]}, "empirical_scope": {"n": 61422, "shares": [0.1764, 0.0262, 0.0029]}, "method_design": {"n": 39751, "shares": [0.133, 0.0147, 0.0011]}, "baselines_ablations": {"n": 26133, "shares": [0.2434, 0.0424, 0.0041]}, "theory": {"n": 38434, "shares": [0.1413, 0.0149, 0.0014]}, "problem_framing": {"n": 7265, "shares": [0.1265, 0.0116, 0.001]}, "novelty": {"n": 9396, "shares": [0.1246, 0.0125, 0.0006]}, "robustness_sensitivity": {"n": 15020, "shares": [0.2405, 0.0542, 0.0072]}, "related_work": {"n": 8965, "shares": [0.2489, 0.0587, 0.0165]}, "compute_cost": {"n": 23596, "shares": [0.2326, 0.0589, 0.0076]}, "stats_metrics": {"n": 31118, "shares": [0.2056, 0.0525, 0.0103]}, "reproducibility": {"n": 6379, "shares": [0.2831, 0.0868, 0.0215]}}, "by_rating": {"0": {"n": 6247, "shares": [0.1868, 0.0352, 0.0045]}, "2": {"n": 92902, "shares": [0.1901, 0.0359, 0.0054]}, "4": {"n": 117937, "shares": [0.1978, 0.0364, 0.0051]}, "6": {"n": 63590, "shares": [0.2104, 0.0413, 0.0064]}, "8": {"n": 12612, "shares": [0.2127, 0.0473, 0.0086]}, "10": {"n": 383, "shares": [0.2454, 0.0679, 0.0052]}}, "pairs": [{"sim": 0.9993, "obj": "related_work", "a": "Inconsistent use of LaTeX citation commands (cite vs. citep).", "b": "Inconsistent use of LaTeX citation commands (cite vs citep).", "pa": "rjhF7b7n6g", "pb": "kDqH5KmRWR", "ra": "DgpP7dvuyO", "rb": "WNlpT9gDYM"}, {"sim": 0.9993, "obj": "related_work", "a": "Inconsistent use of LaTeX citation commands (cite vs citep).", "b": "Inconsistent use of LaTeX citation commands (cite vs. citep).", "pa": "kDqH5KmRWR", "pb": "rjhF7b7n6g", "ra": "WNlpT9gDYM", "rb": "DgpP7dvuyO"}, {"sim": 0.9987, "obj": "related_work", "a": "There are issues with reference formatting within the manuscript.", "b": "There are issues with reference formatting in the manuscript.", "pa": "Xa6QRrXrKX", "pb": "4Lop9ReXBP", "ra": "VUnVipAf49", "rb": "ZReSlEe67s"}, {"sim": 0.9987, "obj": "clarity", "a": "There are issues with reference formatting in the manuscript.", "b": "There are issues with reference formatting within the manuscript.", "pa": "4Lop9ReXBP", "pb": "Xa6QRrXrKX", "ra": "ZReSlEe67s", "rb": "VUnVipAf49"}, {"sim": 0.9981, "obj": "baselines_ablations", "a": "The paper lacks ablation studies isolating the contribution of individual components.", "b": "The paper lacks ablation studies isolating the contributions of individual components.", "pa": "O4f1NdXtdM", "pb": "4VzVWXUkhf", "ra": "LEtit2vyd0", "rb": "3RVeVaxJwR"}, {"sim": 0.9981, "obj": "baselines_ablations", "a": "The paper lacks ablation studies isolating the contributions of individual components.", "b": "The paper lacks ablation studies isolating the contribution of individual components.", "pa": "4VzVWXUkhf", "pb": "O4f1NdXtdM", "ra": "3RVeVaxJwR", "rb": "LEtit2vyd0"}, {"sim": 0.9979, "obj": "empirical_scope", "a": "Experiments are limited to 7B-parameter models.", "b": "Experiments are limited to 7B parameter models.", "pa": "RPflMrUF3O", "pb": "sQHbrMMlse", "ra": "XENdJJYHQc", "rb": "u1fVH1sXkM"}, {"sim": 0.9979, "obj": "stats_metrics", "a": "Experiments are limited to 7B parameter models.", "b": "Experiments are limited to 7B-parameter models.", "pa": "sQHbrMMlse", "pb": "RPflMrUF3O", "ra": "u1fVH1sXkM", "rb": "XENdJJYHQc"}, {"sim": 0.9975, "obj": "compute_cost", "a": "The method requires access to both base and RLVR models during inference.", "b": "The method requires access to both the base and RLVR models during inference.", "pa": "r6Pw3RiMYL", "pb": "xBlHiHdXap", "ra": "K8yQQwHxaG", "rb": "OE02Y0tpFx"}, {"sim": 0.9975, "obj": "compute_cost", "a": "The method requires access to both the base and RLVR models during inference.", "b": "The method requires access to both base and RLVR models during inference.", "pa": "xBlHiHdXap", "pb": "r6Pw3RiMYL", "ra": "OE02Y0tpFx", "rb": "K8yQQwHxaG"}, {"sim": 0.9972, "obj": "stats_metrics", "a": "The paper lacks an analysis of failure cases.", "b": "The paper lacks analysis of failure cases.", "pa": "GonPrE1lch", "pb": "2VWQKehe0D", "ra": "oRp6Wgn8kB", "rb": "1OfMp1UJmn"}, {"sim": 0.9972, "obj": "stats_metrics", "a": "The paper lacks analysis of failure cases.", "b": "The paper lacks an analysis of failure cases.", "pa": "2VWQKehe0D", "pb": "GonPrE1lch", "ra": "1OfMp1UJmn", "rb": "oRp6Wgn8kB"}, {"sim": 0.9958, "obj": "compute_cost", "a": "The experiments are conducted only on small datasets.", "b": "Experiments are conducted only on small datasets.", "pa": "rEjWBDtxoK", "pb": "lZrZgZ9wIu", "ra": "FyculpJWu7", "rb": "CYgd4tZTg3"}, {"sim": 0.9958, "obj": "empirical_scope", "a": "Experiments are conducted only on small datasets.", "b": "The experiments are conducted only on small datasets.", "pa": "lZrZgZ9wIu", "pb": "rEjWBDtxoK", "ra": "CYgd4tZTg3", "rb": "FyculpJWu7"}, {"sim": 0.9954, "obj": "clarity", "a": "The paper uses `cite` instead of `citep`.", "b": "The paper uses `cite` instead of `citep` for citations.", "pa": "I6pTDAQE8V", "pb": "DUpmBHZTmH", "ra": "OQsjMC4yZE", "rb": "b4vVda70oA"}, {"sim": 0.9947, "obj": "empirical_scope", "a": "Experiments are conducted on only one base model.", "b": "Experiments are conducted using only one base model.", "pa": "P7wBg0vPTh", "pb": "XxYNlbTFYS", "ra": "VXeA61j1i3", "rb": "o1Mb3My6eo"}, {"sim": 0.9946, "obj": "clarity", "a": "The reviewer notes the absence of a dedicated 'Limitations' section in the paper.", "b": "The reviewer notes the absence of a dedicated limitations section in the paper.", "pa": "0Xi3WDwd5w", "pb": "gZyEJ2kMow", "ra": "7wOTsoV7Qw", "rb": "i8pYVoxgUP"}, {"sim": 0.9942, "obj": "reproducibility", "a": "The anonymous GitHub repository provided is empty.", "b": "The anonymous GitHub repository is empty.", "pa": "inXScPz1gT", "pb": "RdoXks7VmJ", "ra": "bw8LamlEtu", "rb": "PxqXpg5z2c"}, {"sim": 0.9942, "obj": "reproducibility", "a": "The anonymous GitHub repository is empty.", "b": "The anonymous GitHub repository provided is empty.", "pa": "RdoXks7VmJ", "pb": "inXScPz1gT", "ra": "PxqXpg5z2c", "rb": "bw8LamlEtu"}, {"sim": 0.9938, "obj": "robustness_sensitivity", "a": "Experiments are limited to models with 7B parameters.", "b": "Experiments are limited to 7B parameter models.", "pa": "lnZwKQDhsh", "pb": "sQHbrMMlse", "ra": "HwBYZebv75", "rb": "u1fVH1sXkM"}, {"sim": 0.9931, "obj": "reproducibility", "a": "Source code is absent from the submission.", "b": "The source code is absent from the submission.", "pa": "9LcS3O3Z8m", "pb": "pEtQaGUZVB", "ra": "h1AXCss98v", "rb": "lSsPyxqbn5"}, {"sim": 0.9915, "obj": "baselines_ablations", "a": "The experiments are limited to small datasets.", "b": "Experiments are limited to small-scale datasets.", "pa": "VVstc2W3RW", "pb": "q5ePtZc9N7", "ra": "Qr1GiO8mRW", "rb": "W5cuIEkbmc"}, {"sim": 0.9911, "obj": "method_design", "a": "The paper lacks an ablation study isolating the contributions of individual components.", "b": "The paper lacks ablation studies isolating the contributions of individual components.", "pa": "xToDNYv0GZ", "pb": "4VzVWXUkhf", "ra": "1wnPvSuc4J", "rb": "3RVeVaxJwR"}, {"sim": 0.9902, "obj": "robustness_sensitivity", "a": "The paper lacks an analysis of when and why the system fails.", "b": "The paper lacks an analysis of why the system fails.", "pa": "FqDmvMZish", "pb": "GN8OdkTo3B", "ra": "Pvmm0vmUAH", "rb": "AMczN2JXq1"}], "pairs_boundary": [{"band": "formula", "sim": 0.8985, "obj": "robustness_sensitivity", "a": "The reviewer identifies the mapping as heuristic, noting a lack of principled justification or learned parameters.", "b": "The reviewer identifies the feature encoding as a heuristic lacking principled justification.", "pa": "2NLkhPex1M", "pb": "NnBbr4hI8a", "ra": "2Fwuws1zP2", "rb": "lAbjQyDtAs"}, {"band": "formula", "sim": 0.9008, "obj": "method_design", "a": "The paper lacks baseline comparisons against other inference-time methods, specifically mentioning remasking.", "b": "The paper lacks inference-time comparisons with other methods.", "pa": "BvgTTL4xJH", "pb": "w8oetSFMwO", "ra": "I3uDlJ5cmO", "rb": "hRm4j9inQA"}, {"band": "formula", "sim": 0.8995, "obj": "theory", "a": "The paper does not discuss the key assumptions required for Granger causality to have a valid causal interpretation.", "b": "The paper claims interpretability via Granger causality but provides no qualitative evidence such as visualized causal graphs or case studies.", "pa": "Y7IZlDttMM", "pb": "ctAeamWgUe", "ra": "ThCTtPtA6z", "rb": "bqiO1z1DyS"}, {"band": "formula", "sim": 0.9047, "obj": "compute_cost", "a": "The reviewer notes the paper provides an overall complexity estimate but lacks quantitative comparisons to baselines in terms of runtime, memory, and scalability.", "b": "The reviewer notes that the paper discusses computational complexity analytically but lacks empirical runtime data compared to baselines.", "pa": "weWUOuLTdj", "pb": "vIecIscDJf", "ra": "JNW3zAzEJs", "rb": "i0BjuZUaFn"}, {"band": "formula", "sim": 0.9066, "obj": "compute_cost", "a": "The paper lacks explicit theoretical guarantees specifying under what conditions the proposed method outperforms existing approaches.", "b": "The paper lacks theoretical proof for the proposed method's accuracy advantage over existing methods.", "pa": "SbMWnYTJNj", "pb": "wuncwN7iZN", "ra": "OzIYjyWxjy", "rb": "Gw8vaqy2SB"}, {"band": "formula", "sim": 0.8979, "obj": "theory", "a": "The convergence of the optimization process is not analyzed.", "b": "The paper does not provide a convergence analysis for the optimization method.", "pa": "a5aRjldX9l", "pb": "BBlE9cuKFa", "ra": "Cv0gkUKKbm", "rb": "jl9faSYucH"}, {"band": "familiar", "sim": 0.8538, "obj": "clarity", "a": "Analyses are described as descriptive, empirical, correlational, or mere measurements without theoretical explanation.", "b": "The analysis of experimental results is descriptive, merely reporting numbers without deeper insight.", "pa": "ibXhUapwcz", "pb": "jWaQA9BvtI", "ra": "dbwMWkGpRj", "rb": "EJmMFA0WVp"}, {"band": "familiar", "sim": 0.8506, "obj": "baselines_ablations", "a": "The paper benchmarks only against standard embeddings (SBERT) with conventional clustering (KMeans, GMM) and its own ablations, omitting strong baselines from multi-view clustering and ensemble methods.", "b": "Clustering results show that SAE and dense embeddings produce different clusters, but do not demonstrate that SAE clusters are better in any meaningful sense, nor are they falsified or verified against ground truth.", "pa": "egPSakPG0e", "pb": "yB4imIAR0J", "ra": "22EQc5Eogf", "rb": "duhURHZwT6"}, {"band": "familiar", "sim": 0.8557, "obj": "method_design", "a": "The paper mentions curating a training set but does not explain how it is used for training purposes.", "b": "The paper mentions 'training and test errors' but does not clearly define them or state their values.", "pa": "nXJmbeMHDQ", "pb": "Ochp5HHp46", "ra": "LnwcUt2y5C", "rb": "sIccwRWdBp"}, {"band": "familiar", "sim": 0.853, "obj": "theory", "a": "The reviewer demanded a proof or derivation for Equation (6).", "b": "The reviewer finds the derivation leading to Equation (6) unclear and requests a step-by-step breakdown.", "pa": "RHPqr2egJO", "pb": "XyQ5ui62mm", "ra": "uIsvP4IIJH", "rb": "syOLa3Msy1"}, {"band": "familiar", "sim": 0.8459, "obj": "method_design", "a": "The reviewer finds the visual demonstrations compelling but notes the absence of quantitative metrics such as speed, gait stability, or tracking error.", "b": "The reviewer finds visual examples convincing but notes the absence of perceptual metrics (e.g., LPIPS, FID) or user studies.", "pa": "WELrlKB4be", "pb": "SbLj5hJXh6", "ra": "6BooH3NHKS", "rb": "zefYP0BTgz"}, {"band": "familiar", "sim": 0.8484, "obj": "clarity", "a": "Absence of camera trajectory visualizations and diverse scene comparisons.", "b": "Missing visual comparisons with real images, unclear release plans, and absent limitations discussion", "pa": "briHoZDErt", "pb": "34KcfeU2AO", "ra": "DRazxDeQ1H", "rb": "5TzyEHFoUB"}]}